Chapter Text
Silence settled between you. For a split second Eddie had looked pretty pleased with himself but now he was staring at you intensely.
You locked eyes with him, afraid if you looked away it would all disappear, just another dream gone up in smoke. The feeling of his fingers on your hips made you inhale sharply. He traced small circles into your skin—you missed the warmth of his hands on your chest.
Without breaking eye contact you reached down and grabbed the hem of your sweatshirt. You lifted it up slowly, dragging it languidly off your frame, and tossed it across the room. Immediately you began fighting the need to cover yourself but knew you were losing, the pressure of not knowing what Eddie thought of your half-naked body caused you to hug yourself with an embarrassed laugh.
“Don’t.” Eddie said softly, giving you a look you’d never seen before. His eyes were blown and hungry and filled with something you couldn’t place. Your heart stirred at the thought of it being more than just lust. Moving his hands from your hips he reached out and gently grabbed your arms, bringing them down to your lap. He stroked your palms slowly with his thumbs.
“You’re the most beautiful thing I’ve ever seen.” He finally said, looking like he’d just gotten a huge weight off his chest.
“Do you want to touch me, Eddie?”
“More than anything, princess.” You felt your stomach flip, the nickname sounding dirty now given your current position wrapped around Eddie’s waist, his erection still pressing into your leg.
Wrapping your hands around his, you lifted them to your bare chest, urging him to explore more than his cautious touches before. Your nipples hardened at the sensation of cool air and Eddie’s rough skin.
Slowly, you began to guide his hands, showing him how to squeeze and knead your breasts the way you did when you were alone, the way you did when you thought of him in bed.
You’d have to tell him about those nights later, you had a feeling he’d be very interested.
Eddie looked at you like one bewitched, drinking in the sight of your skin with his hungry eyes. Almost as if snapping out of a trance, he surprised you by leaning forward and taking your right nipple in his mouth, sucking on it needfully.
You let out a cry at the foreign sensation and rocked into Eddie, eager for any of release to the tight ball of wet heat growing between your legs. If you moved just right you could feel his cock brush up against your center. You rocked into him again desperately.
“Eddie, I need you to touch me,” you pled between heavy breaths.
“I am touching you, princess” he managed to choke out, releasing your nipple with a pop, now turning his attention to the other.
“‘No. I need you to touch me.”
You felt drunk with desire and knew you probably looked deranged and needy but you didn’t care.
Without taking his mouth off your nipple he carefully slipped his hand through the leg of your shorts, ghosting over your panties which were growing wetter by the second.
Thank god you’d put on a halfway decent pair today, you thought, although something told you Eddie was more interested in what was underneath them than what they looked like.
Impatient with his careful movements you pushed your body into his hand and gasped at the new pressure of his palm against your clit.
“Eddie…” you whined.
Finally getting the memo, he moved your panties to the side and ran a finger down the length of your pussy, lingering at your entrance before pushing into the promised land.
“Fuck, you’re so wet” he whispered as he began to kiss you again, his tongue exploring your mouth.
You tried to respond, but all that came out was a garbled mess of sounds as you felt him push deeper inside you.
“Does it feel good baby?” He grunted breathlessly into your mouth.
Your brain was clouded with sex and you answered him by rocking slowly on his finger, cursing as he curled it inside you.
He surprised you again by rubbing his thumb across your clit, rolling it in a small circle while he pumped his finger into you faster.
You had no idea where he’d learned to do that. All the issues of Cosmo you’d stolen from your mom talked about the clit like it was a hidden temple men wouldn’t know how to find even if it fell on them. But Eddie sure as hell knew how to find it.
You felt something building inside you, reminding you of all the times you’d touched yourself under the covers thinking of Eddie but stopped when you felt guilty and too scared to fall over the edge. This was so much better.
“Don’t stop Eddie!” you cried. “Please I’m…I’m close.”
He pulled back slightly and brought his other hand to your pussy, too, now using two fingers on one hand to fuck you while he picked up the pace on your clit with the other. You felt like you were going to die.
“God I’m going to…”
Lurching forward violently, you screamed into Eddie’s shoulder as you felt your orgasm rip through you. Stars blocked your vision and you felt the world go fuzzy at the edges. In that moment, everything else fell away and you felt like you were floating above yourself, looking down at just a girl and a boy who’d finally found each other.
You collapsed into Eddie, hugging him tightly against you.
“Jesus fuck, Eddie,” you managed to squeak out, “where the fuck did you learn to do that?”
“Our Bodies, Ourselves,” he said into your hair, hugging you back tightly.
“You’ve read Our Bodies, Ourselves?”
“I may have skimmed some very specific parts.”
You shot him a look of disbelief, still reeling from your orgasm, before you both broke into laughter.
“I think I might need to reread it.” you said, kissing him lightly, tugging on his bottom lip with your teeth.
“Can I level with you?”
“Eddie Munson. After what you just did to me you can tell me anything.” You pressed a sloppy kiss into his cheek and he theatrically wiped it away, feigning disgust before continuing.
“That was the hottest goddamn thing I’ve ever seen. I actually…umm…” he cleared his throat, “I came in my pants.”
You looked down between you and sure enough there was a small wet spot forming on the denim. You smiled sweetly at the boy underneath you.
“Do you want to do it again? But, you know, this time not in your pants?” You asked, never having thought you’d say those words to Eddie Munson of all people.
Eddie nodded and looked to you for what to do next.
Grabbing his hand, you unwrapped yourself from his waist, already missing his body heat between your legs, and pulled him up with you.
You stood in front of one another, your mutual nervousness filling the air. Making the first move you pulled down your shorts leaving yourself only in your black panties.
“Before I reveal grand finale,” you said, “we really need to get you out of your clothes.” You eyed Eddie mischievously as you picked at the collar of his vest, tugging on it slightly.
He began pulling off his clothes with unmatched speed, stripping off his jacket and shirt. You tried to hold back your laughter as he stumbled and hopped, struggling to get out of his ripped jeans.
Once he was was free, you raked your eyes across his body, taking in every tattoo and freckle. You made a mental note to kiss them later. He was beautiful in a way you couldn’t put into words and you wanted him more than anything.
“Should we do it together?” He asked, breaking the silence between you as he gestured at the final piece of clothing keeping both of you apart.
“On the count of three?”
Eddie nodded, “on the count of three.”
“1…2…3”
You dropped the final curtain at the same time.
Eddie’s erection bounced out of his boxers as he dropped them to his feet. Over the years at sleepovers you and your friends had giggled over copies of Playgirl always found hidden in some nightstand. You felt like you’d seen the whole range of cocks at this point, an expert at looking without ever touching. With your trained eye you noted happily that Eddie fell somewhere on the upper side of average. He was perfect.
You saw him taking in the sight of your naked body all at once, savoring each piece with his eyes as he slowly moved down.
You both stepped forward at the same time eager to feel each other again, this time with no clothes in the way. Eddie kissed you slower this time, the hunger still there but morphing into something different. This was comfort and familiarity like slipping under the covers and into a long nap after spending too much time in the sun.
You walked Eddie backwards into your bed until the back of his knees hit the mattress causing him to buckle and fall back.
You climbed in after him and after a minute of awkward maneuvering and giggling you lay facing one another gazing into each other’s eyes.
“Can I tell you a secret?” He asked, playing with a strand of your hair before brushing it behind your ear.
“Remember that day in the woods when you fell?” Your heart beat wildly. “I wanted to kiss you so bad,” Eddie smiled wistfully, “you were so pretty and I thought, ‘Munson if you don’t do it now you’ll never get another chance.’ And then you moved and I…I didn’t know how to get you back.”
“Can I tell you a secret?” Eddie nodded, leaning in to kiss your forehead. “I listened to the album you gave me so many times after we moved I thought I would wear a hole in the cover, and…and your copy of the The Fellowship of the Ring you gave me? Eddie, I read it almost every night to fall asleep. And…just…even though Hawkins is an extra-planar hell hole, I think I’ve loved you since the first day I met you.”
Once the words had started you couldn’t stop them from coming out. Everything fucked in the world and in Hawkins and in your life and Eddie’s had been piling up on top of you. When “I love you,” left your lips you felt like you could breathe again.
“It’s always been you,” Eddie whispered, mouthing your name softly into your ear, “I love you, too.”
You slipped into a lazy haze of kisses and touches as you pressed your bodies together. Eddie slotted his thigh between your legs, pushing up against your pussy, still sensitive from his fingers.
Armed with the knowledge that Eddie Munson loved you, you reached between your bodies and wrapped your hand around Eddie’s hard cock.
He gasped at the feeling of your hand and bucked into it unconsciously.
“You…you don’t have to touch me,” he gasped, bucking into your hand again. Ignoring him, you began stroking him and rubbed your thumb experimentally across the head, coating his cock with the wetness that was leaking from the tip.
“I need you Eddie.” You said, “I love you and I need you.”
“Are you sure? I don’t want you to do anything you’ll regret.”
“Eddie, I could never regret this. Just go slow, okay?”
Eddie broke away from you, the two of you shifting around again until he was on top of you, holding himself above you on shaky arms.
“Just breathe.” You whispered softly into his lips, eager to feel him inside you.
“Can you…can you help me?” Eddie gestured down, blush creeping across his cheeks. You reached down and grabbed his cock slowly. Carefully, you lined Eddie up with your entrance, still wet and hot with need.
“I’m ready.”
The sound of Eddie’s groan and your whine as he slowly pushed into you mixed together in the air. A flash of stinging white ripped through you for a split second, immediately giving way to a feeling unlike anything you’d ever known. Eddie’s cock fit into you perfectly as if made to fill only your body. Despite having told him to go slow, you were eating your words, you needed him fast and hard.
You bucked your hips upward, pushing him deeper inside. Eddie moaned as he pulled out slightly and pushed into you again.
“Feel…so good.” Eddie panted picking up the pace of his thrusts, quickly finding a rhythm that made you both cry out in pleasure.
“Fuck me, Eddie, please, please…” you trailed off, unable to hold a coherent thought while he slammed into your tight hole making your pussy clench around him.
“Can’t go much longer…” Eddie choked out between thrusts. You loved the way his bit his lip, his face contorting with pleasure.
“Where? Where do I cum?” He asked frantically.
“On the pill! I’m on the pill!” You let out almost more primal scream than words. “Cum inside me Eddie!” You begged him, “Please fill me up!”
“Fuck. You…you can’t just say things like that. God I’m…FUCK!”
You felt something hot spill inside of you as Eddie’s cock twitched—you squeezed your pussy around him, milking out every drop.
Only the sound of heavy breathing filled the room. You and Eddie both lay on your backs and stared up at the ceiling, utterly spent.
After a while, Eddie whispered your name. You rolled to your side and nuzzled into him, fitting your head under his chin. He wrapped his arms tightly around you, pulling your quilt up to cover you both.
“So, what happens now?” You whispered quietly into Eddie’s chest.
“Whatever milady commands.” Eddie said, you could feel the smile cross his lips above you.
“Your lady commands you confess your love to her again.” You laughed, burying your face as deeply as you could into him, savoring his warmth.
“I love you more than anything.” Eddie responded. “I love you more than life.”
“More than D&D?”
Eddie gasped like a scandalized church lady, “How dare you ask me to choose between my two great loves!”
You giggled at his theatrics, moving in to kiss him when you heard a familiar noise that made you both jump.
Tap.
Tap.
“What the fuck is that? How many people are going to chuck rocks at my window tonight?” You asked Eddie.
“You have another boyfriend I need to know about?” He asked, climbing over you out of bed to pull on his jeans.
“Boyfriend, huh?” You shot him a wide smile as he crept towards your cracked window, turning back to smile at you.
“Eddie!!! Wait….why don’t you have a shirt on?” You heard the voice of a boy from outside that sounded like Dustin Henderson.
“How did he even know where to find you?” You hissed at Eddie who stood sheepishly at the window, too mortified to speak.
Scrambling to pull on your sweatshirt you joined Eddie at the window. Outside your house was much more than just Dustin Henderson. It was like Harrington and Co. everyone stared up at you both, your disheveled hair and the blossoming red marks on both Eddie’s neck and your own giving anyone with eyes the truth of what had just happened in your room.
You heard someone giggle and you looked down to see Steve and Robin whispering to each other, stopping quickly when they realized you’d caught them.
“Just…all of you meet us in the back.”
You closed the window quickly and turned to Eddie.
“I’ll ask again, how did they know where to find you?”
“I may have mentioned to Henderson once how much I liked you and how, if I needed to be safe, I’d come here.” He rubbed the back of his neck, looking embarrassed that he’d forgotten to mention such a crucial detail earlier. You guessed you both had been preoccupied with other…things.
“Jesus Christ, that’s like the sappiest thing I’ve ever heard.” You sighed and stepped forward to kiss him, bringing up a hand to softly brush his cheek.
“Should we let them in?” He asked, even though everything on his face screamed that he was cursing his friends for interrupting his post-coital bliss and a potential round two.
Grabbing your shorts and pulling them back on you walked towards Eddie and grabbed his hand. You stopped short of the door and turned to look at him.
“No matter what they have to say just remember that I love you, Eddie Munson.”
“More than D&D?” He asked with that damned smiled.
You turned the doorknob and began to walk towards the stairs, pulling Eddie along behind you. You looked back at him over your shoulder, wishing you could freeze this exact moment in time and live in it forever.
“More than D&D.”