Chapter Text
"Oh my fucking god." You say. Of course, Dean is with another slutty girl. What a dick he can be, but you gotta say, you had a lot of strong feelings for him. He never knew this of course, which led him to keep sleeping with girls. But It was just another day. Come on, Y/N, he's been like this for the, what? 10 years you've been with the Winchesters. "What-Oh" Sam starts. "You know Y/N, I'm really sorry that my brother is a blind dumb ass. He really keeps looking in the wrong places."
"Yeah, you don't say." You sigh loudly. "You know what, that dumb ass really needs to be confronted on his fucking slutty ass."
"Don't worry about it, Y/N, he'll get Herpes one day." Sam says to you.
"Ha! Thanks Sam, I just- just want to go home now." You look down holding back tears.
"Okay, we can walk there, it's only a mile away. Okay Y/N?" He asks you when you seem distracted.
"Oh, yeah sorry. I was just-" You start to say. It was obvious you were looking at that girl and Dean. Come on, she was so hard to beat! She was skinny, you were sorta' chubby. She had a beautiful smile, you looked like you came out of a failure factory.
"Y/N, my dickhead brother doesn't deserve you if he treats you like this." Sam interrupts you with a gentle smile. "Come on, let's leave."
"Hey, Y/N, Sam, where you going? Dean asks you two with a suggestion to stay here and have fun only because he's having fun.
"Oh wow, I'm surprised you got your mind off of tits and ass." You say to him. It's true, why did he stop you now, he could have gotten into that girl's pants already.
"What, why-why would you say that, you know that I-" Dean starts.
"Oh don't start Dean, go fuck another chick, you never cared about Y/N." Sam says with a disgusted look on his face.
~The Walk To The Bunker~
"Wow, thanks for standing up to him for me like that. That was really nice Sam." You say to Sam. That was true, Sam has been there to wipe your tears and pat your back when you cry.
"Don't thank me, he deserves it." Sam said seriously with anger.
"Yeah-" You start.
"No, really he doesn't love you like I do." Sam finished with a gentle smile.
Wait, what? Did Sam fucking Winchester said that he loves me? Oh my Cas! This makes total sense! He's been there for you this whole time! He finished off his brother for you. Oh my Cas, he loves you! Sam loves you! Sam loves you!
"I-I, Sam,I" You can't answer because SAM FUCKING WINCHESTER LOVES YOU! And you loved him too! You've been looking in the wrong places, he was always there for you!
"It's fine, I'm sorry, I'm just drunk." Sam tries to play it off cool.
"No Sam, you've always been there for me, and I guess I was the one looking in the wrong places this whole time." Your cheeks turn pink. You shakily reach out for his hand and-OMC HE'S HOLDING YOUR HAND!
"I think this might work out for us, Sam." You say sweetly to Sam.
"Oh there is an 'us', I never said there is an 'us'." Sam chuckles and kids with you.
Of course you giggle, and you giggled the whole way to the bunker. You and Sam had your first connection at an intersection. Well, Y/N it was better than no connection right? You ask yourself. You and Sam talked and joked the whole way home.
~The Bunker~
"So that's how I accidentally had a threesome with Taylor Swift and Selena Gomez" Sam finishes off his story.
"Oh my Cas! You actually scored two famous chicks! Ahh...Was Dean jealous?"
"Oh yeah, Y/N, you don't realize how much he loves Taylor Swift, he makes fun of her just so he can 'play it off'." Sam finishes. Sam told you how he had to stand up with his jerk brother for 32 whole years!
You stand on his feet just to reach up and kiss him. You put your legs around his waist and he cups your ass. He carries you over to the bedroom. {NOT A SEX SCENE} He gives you a suggestive look and pulls out a condom after he planted you on top of the bed.
"Uh no Sam, you know I-I can't." You have a phobia of sex, Dean calls it 'an unfortunate curse', Of course that dick would, but Sam he understands you and has always been the one to hold your hair back to puke when you see Dean (or anyone) go off to have sex. It absolutely DISGUSTS you.
"Oh, I'm sorry, I thought it would change because umm..." He coughs awkwardly "...yeah sorry."
"I wish it would change, but, you gotta love phobias." You finish.
He slips out of his clothes and only in his boxers. (for you <3) You get changed into your super comfy Superman bra and panties. (for special occasions) Hey, just because you can't 'do it', doesn't mean you can't have super awesome geek underwear!
"I love you Sam, and I'm sorry I've been head over heels for your brother, I wish I could have known sooner." You say.
"Hey, Y/N, better than nothing, right?" Sam asks you.
"Yeah, totally right."
Sam and you have a makeout sesh. (<3) And cuddle all night long. Way better than sex!