Actions

Work Header

If Only it Was Me Since the Beginning

Summary:

Reader joined the gang after being found as a young, 13 year old girl, where she met a 17 year old Arthur Morgan. At 19 years old, she got pregnant by a dishonorable man. He left her alone with her child, but luckily, the gang was there to help.

This story starts directly after the child was born, basically a month or two after. This is why Arthur and the gang are not too acustomed to him yet.

Notes:

(See the end of the work for notes.)

Chapter 1: Moving Day- Shady Belle

Chapter Text

When the gang finally arrives at the camp, Shady Belle, the worn-out mansion seems to loom over them with an ominous presence. The walls are crumbling, and the once-grand architecture is now shrouded in decay. The marshland that surrounds the area adds a thick, humid atmosphere, making the place feel even more oppressive. The murky water reflects the darkening sky, casting an eerie glow over the campsite.

 

As the group dismounts, there’s a tense, almost anticipatory silence. The gang is exhausted, both physically and mentally, from their journey and recent losses. They all stand in front of the mansion, unsure of what to make of this new place that they are supposed to call home. The once-vibrant group is now riddled with fatigue and uncertainty.

 

Dutch, ever the leader, is the first to break the silence. “Well, folks, it ain’t much, but it’s shelter. We’ll make do,” he says, trying to inject some semblance of optimism into his voice. But there’s a hollowness to his words that isn’t lost on anyone.

 

Everyone slowly begins to move, unpacking their belongings and setting up their tents and makeshift sleeping areas. Hosea, usually quick with a joke or a reassuring word, is quiet as he directs the others on where to set up camp. Javier and Bill start checking the perimeter, ensuring the area is secure, though the idea of safety feels more like an illusion these days.

 

You keep close to your son, the both of you huddled together as you take in the surroundings. The place is unsettling, but after being on the run for so long, you’re grateful for any kind of shelter. You notice how everyone moves around you with a strange mix of curiosity and wariness. They aren’t sure what to say or do with you just having a child, hell, the last one was born six years ago. 

 

As the gang starts settling in, you begin to notice more and more how Arthur is different from the others. He’s always been a man of few words, but now there’s something even more distant about him. He’s withdrawn, more so than usual, keeping to himself as he quietly helps the others without saying much. He avoids any unnecessary conversation, and his interactions with the gang are limited to what’s needed to get the camp in order. His eyes are shadowed, the exhaustion and the weight of everything they’ve been through apparent in his every move.

 

At one point, you catch Arthur’s gaze as he watches you with your son from across the camp. There’s something in his expression—a mixture of sadness, regret, and something else you can’t quite place. It’s like he’s seeing something in you that reminds him of something—or someone—he’s lost.

 

As night falls, the camp is bathed in the dim light of a few campfires. The gang gathers around the largest fire, trying to find some comfort in the warmth and the company of one another. Lenny and Sean share a bottle of whiskey, trying to lift everyone’s spirits with half-hearted jokes and stories. But even their laughter sounds forced, like everyone is trying too hard to pretend that things are still normal.

 

You find yourself gravitating toward Arthur’s tent, needing some space away from the others. Ever since joining the gang, he’s always let you go there when you need alone time. Your son has fallen asleep in your arms, his small body finally relaxed after the long day. The sounds of the campfire and the murmured conversations fade into the background as you step into Arthur’s tent. It’s sparse, with only the bare essentials—his bedroll, some scattered belongings, and a small table with a few personal items on it. The smell of tobacco and leather lingers in the air, along with a hint of something more earthy, like the scent of the wilderness itself.

 

You carefully lay your son down on Arthur’s bedroll, trying not to wake him. For a moment, you just stand there, watching him sleep. The tension in your shoulders eases just a little, knowing that for now, he’s safe.

 

Suddenly, you hear the soft rustle of the tent flap behind you. You turn to see Arthur standing there, his tall figure casting a long shadow in the dim light. His expression is unreadable, but there’s a softness in his eyes as he looks at you and then at your sleeping son.

 

“I didn’t mean to intrude,” you say quietly, feeling suddenly self-conscious for being in his space without permission.

 

Arthur shakes his head slightly. “You’re not intruding,” he replies, his voice low and rough. He steps inside the tent, closing the flap behind him, and then pauses, almost unsure of what to do next.

 

There’s a heavy silence between you, filled with unspoken words and emotions. After a moment, Arthur walks over to where your son is sleeping and kneels down beside him. He hesitates for a second before gently reaching out, his large, calloused hand cradling the tiny form of your son. The baby stirs slightly but doesn’t wake up, settling comfortably in Arthur’s arms.

 

Arthur’s expression softens as he holds the child, the hardness in his features melting away. For the first time in what feels like ages, you see a glimmer of something tender in his eyes—something vulnerable.

 

“He’s a good kid,” Arthur says quietly, his voice barely above a whisper. “Strong, too. Takes after his mother, I reckon.”

 

His words catch you off guard, and you feel a lump forming in your throat. You’re not used to such kindness, especially from someone as guarded as Arthur. “Thank you,” you manage to say, your voice thick with emotion.

 

Arthur looks up at you, his blue eyes locking onto yours. There’s a connection between you in that moment, something unspoken but deeply understood. He knows what it’s like to carry the weight of the world on your shoulders, to be responsible for someone else in a world that’s falling apart.

 

For a long while, neither of you says anything. The camp outside seems worlds away, and it’s just the three of you in this small, quiet space. You watch as Arthur gently rocks your son, his movements careful and deliberate, as if he’s afraid of breaking something fragile.

 

Eventually, Arthur speaks again, his voice soft and introspective. “Ain’t no easy life we’re livin’, but… it’s worth fightin’ for. You keep holdin’ on to that, y’hear?”

 

You nod, feeling a warmth spread through your chest. There’s something comforting about Arthur’s presence, something solid and reassuring. “I will,” you promise, and you mean it.

 

Arthur holds your son for a little while longer before carefully placing him back on the bedroll. The baby stirs again but doesn’t wake, his tiny hand clutching at the fabric of Arthur’s coat for a moment before settling down again.

 

Arthur stands up slowly, his gaze lingering on you for a moment before he turns to leave. But just as he reaches the tent flap, he pauses and looks back at you. “If you ever need anything… don’t hesitate to ask,” he says, his voice firm but gentle.

 

You nod, giving him a small, grateful smile. “Thank you, Arthur.”

 

He nods in return, then steps out of the tent, leaving you alone with your sleeping son. The sounds of the campfire and the distant voices of the gang filter back in, but they seem less oppressive now. You feel a sense of peace, however fleeting, knowing that you’re not alone in this world.

 

As you sit down beside your son, watching him sleep, you can’t help but think about how far you’ve come—and how much further you have to go. But for now, in this moment, you allow yourself to feel something you haven’t felt in a long time: hope.

 

And as the night deepens, the camp slowly quiets down, the firelight casting long shadows over the tired faces of the gang. In the darkness, Arthur lingers on the outskirts, watching over the camp, his thoughts heavy but his heart just a little bit lighter.