Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Category:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2024-10-09
Updated:
2024-10-17
Words:
6,086
Chapters:
5/?
Comments:
155
Kudos:
124
Bookmarks:
6
Hits:
3,948

Am I the Asshole?

Summary:

A series of short Fictional Reddit Am I the Asshole posts in reference to past fics that I’ve written! Feel free to treat it as a normal AITA post, and respond YTA/NTA, etc.

1) Obsession: My brother slept with my girlfriend while we were at our family weekend
2) Obsession: My little brother put me in a really awkward position and now I think I’ve lost my girlfriend because of it (NSFW)
3) Obsession: UPDATE: My brother slept with my girlfriend while we were at our family weekend
4) Obsession: I blew up on my brother during our holiday and now he won’t talk to me
5) Netflix show: I believe I’m falling in love with my sister’s fiance

Notes:

I have always wanted to write these! I’ll be coming back here to add more in the future.

Chapter 1: Obsession: Gregory

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Fic universe: Obsession

/GreggieB7

My brother slept with my girlfriend while we were at our family weekend

I (22m) brought my girlfriend (25f) to my family weekend in the country a few weeks ago. 

A little backstory first. I met her, let’s call her Kath, at a club in the city. We danced for a little bit before we both went back to my flat and slept together. I got her number and we started to date.

At the time, she had a couple different blokes she slept with regularly, but I really liked her, so I kept asking her out and she kept saying yes. We didn’t have a lot of sex, I think she liked things a certain way, and I was still learning. 

At some point when we were hanging out I thought she was getting ready to break up with me, so I figured I had one last shot at this. I asked her to join me for a family weekend, explaining that we have a big house in the country with a pool and a lake. She agreed to go.

On the way there, I asked her to be my girlfriend and she said yes, but also to see how the weekend goes. 

I thought things were going well, she met my family and everyone seemed to like her. Though I felt bad when I tried to give her a drink before she told me she doesn’t drink alcohol. 

I am the second youngest of a lot of kids, don’t ask, I try not to think about what my parents got up to. When my dad died my eldest brother, let’s call him Tony (36), stepped up and practically raised all of us, even though he was only eighteen at the time. He didn’t have a lot of time for himself, but he did go to uni, get his degree, get a good job, and got married. He and his wife have two kids, 5 and 10.

I always wanted to be like Tony so when I finally had a girlfriend who I saw a future with, I brought her mainly because I wanted her to meet my brother because he’s basically my dad.

At first I didn’t really notice anything happening between them. One night Kath snuck out of our room for an hour or two after going to sleep, but we had sex the second she came back, so I assumed she’d just been reading or watching TV. 

They also never really talked in front of me, so I have no idea how this all progressed. I am sure they never met before that weekend!

On the first full day we were all at the pool and I remember my brother rushing to go to the bathroom, then Kath told me her stomach was upset, so she ran in as well. They both came back out around the same time like thirty minutes later. Would they have really gone inside just then to have sex? It was the first full day there!

Really, though, I found out for sure on the last night. I got really drunk and ended up going to bed early, though most of my siblings were staying up to play drinking games. Kath doesn’t drink so I thought she’d join me, but she stayed down there with them. I fell asleep and when I woke up at like five in the morning, she still wasn’t there.

I thought maybe she slept on the couch or something, because I snore when I’m drunk, but when I went downstairs she was nowhere to be found. I felt kind of sick so I sat down, and then like twenty minutes go by and Kath and Tony walk through the back door together, each with these gigantic smiles on their faces. I’ve never seen Kath smile like that. Plus, they were half naked. Kath’s hair was all loose, her dress wasn’t even zipped, and Tony’s shirt was unbuttoned.

I knew immediately what they had done. Plus, when they saw me, I was sure I was right based on the looks on their faces.

I saw red, went up to pack my stuff up, and drove home straight away. I actually live in a flat my brother Tony bought that he had been letting me stay in and I couldn’t even stand the sight of it, so I went back to my old room at my mum’s.

Tony keeps trying to reach out but I don’t even want to talk to him. The worst part is I heard my brother is divorcing his wife because he wants to be with Kath. 

I hate him so much I can’t see straight.

Now, though, my mum is telling me I should forgive him, because he’s my brother, my blood, and he loves me, but she’s also keeping him away until I’m ready. Tony was there through everything but I can’t get over this. I still hate him, and if he stays with Kath, I’ll have to see them together, and remember that my brother stole her from me. 

My little sister (19f) is on my side and the rest of the family is split. Some of them always had an issue with Tony, so they are mad at him, but my eldest sister (32) and brother (35) are also taking his side, saying it’s because they’re in love. 

My oldest brother slept with his husband when he was still married so of course he’d take Tony’s side!

How could they be in love after one fucking weekend?? What did I do that was so wrong to deserve this? 

Notes:

So, who is the asshole? Feel free to ask for more info and I’ll do my best to respond as OP!