Work Text:
The sun dipped low behind the Hollywood Hills, casting a warm, golden light that washed over the city. Taylor Swift took a deep breath as she stepped onto the balcony of her downtown apartment, watching the city come alive with flickering lights and muted sounds. Somewhere out there, she knew he was waiting.
They were so different in so many ways, yet something about Matthew Gray Gubler kept her coming back, over and over. *“You got that long hair, slicked back, white T-shirt,”* she thought with a smile, remembering his easy, natural charm. The last time she’d seen him, they’d parted in a rush of words, emotions tumbling out faster than they could be contained. But somehow, he was always in her mind, like a melody she couldn’t stop humming.
Tonight, she felt his pull again, and as if on cue, her phone buzzed with a text. She saw his name flash across the screen.
*Are you busy tonight?*
She bit her lip, hesitating for only a second before sending her reply.
*Meet me at our spot?*
---
A half-hour later, Taylor was on the road, her car’s headlights cutting through the California night. She knew this route by heart now, knew the turns and bends that led to the cliffside overlook that had become their sanctuary. The familiar rhythm of the drive brought the memories rushing back—their laughter, the way he’d reach over and brush his fingers against hers on the console, how he’d look at her with those eyes that saw right through her.
When she pulled into the small, secluded overlook, her heart leaped. There he was, leaning against his car, hands in his pockets, his hair slightly tousled in the wind. *“You got that James Dean daydream look in your eye,”* she thought, her heart catching at the sight of him.
She parked, stepping out of her car with a smile tugging at her lips. “You’re here early,” she said, crossing her arms with a playful smirk.
He shrugged, stepping forward, his eyes warm and familiar. “Guess I couldn’t wait to see you.”
A silence settled between them, thick with unspoken words and the electricity that always seemed to spark in the air when they were close. Taylor sighed, her gaze dropping to the ground before looking back up at him.
“Why do we keep doing this, Matt?” she asked, her voice soft, but edged with the kind of vulnerability she rarely showed.
He reached out, his fingers brushing a stray strand of hair from her face. “Because we can’t help it,” he said softly, his voice barely more than a whisper. “You know we’re just drawn back here, to each other. Every time.”
She knew he was right. There was a magnetic pull between them that neither distance nor time could erase. They had tried to move on, to live separate lives, but somehow, they always ended up back here, back in each other’s orbit. *“We never go out of style, do we?”* she murmured, a slight tremor in her voice.
He smiled, a sad, knowing smile. “We’re always going to be unfinished, Taylor. Maybe that’s just our style.”
They stood there, inches apart, hearts beating in sync as the night wrapped around them. He took her hand, bringing it to his lips, and for a moment, she let herself believe they could make this work. She let herself forget the missed calls, the misunderstandings, the jealousy that came with two people living high-profile lives.
But then he wrapped her in his arms, drawing her close, and in that embrace, everything else faded away. The world fell away until there was only the two of them, like they’d been pulled from the pages of her lyrics.
“Stay with me tonight,” he whispered into her hair, a plea she could feel through every fiber of her being. She knew that, come morning, they’d go their separate ways once again, carrying the pieces of each other in their hearts.
For now, though, they’d be each other’s dream—a love that would *“take them back in time.”* And as she rested her head against his chest, listening to his heartbeat, Taylor knew that no matter how many times they left, they’d always come back. Because something as electric as this? *“It never goes out of style.”*