Work Text:
The graduation ceremony tasted like sweet cardboard and sun that was too white. Hawkins knew how to pretend. Hawkins had always known how to pretend.
The black gowns swallowed silhouettes and spit out faces that looked older than before, as if eighteen months had hauled everyone upward by the nape of the neck. Mike wore that slightly broken smile he kept for days when he refused to count the dead. Will blinked against the glare, already elsewhere, already packing memories into imaginary boxes. Dustin talked to someone from too close, hands restless, as if his sentences needed extra air to breathe. Lucas kept an arm around Max, a simple, steady gesture built to say: I’m here. I stayed.
Nancy clapped when it was time to clap. She smiled when it was time to smile. She answered “how are you?” the way you stamp papers.
Then she saw her.
Robin wasn’t in the center. Robin was never in the center, even when she was the engine. She stood off to the side, half-hidden behind a family that wasn’t hers, like a musical note stuck to the edge of a staff, ready to bolt if someone looked at her too directly.
And yet, impossible to miss.
First, because of the hair.
Long. Really long now, not “three months of growth” but “I lived through the world collapsing and I kept existing.” It fell over her shoulders with a superb kind of disobedience, a little wavy where it must have been tied up too often, too fast. It gave her something softer and also something more… dangerous. As if her face, already bright, had gained a seductive shadow simply from being framed differently.
For a second, Nancy had a stupid, precise thought: they finally stopped sticking something on her head. Not mean, more like relief. Robin looked more like Robin than ever.
Then, because of her body.
During custody, Robin had melted away. Nancy remembered the unromantic thinness, bones pushing under oversized t-shirts, that forced energy that sounded like “I’m fine” while everything screamed “not at all.” And now… now, life had taken back ground.
Not “like before,” not a magic erase, not a return to an intact version of herself. More like a reconquest. Presence back in her cheeks, in her arms, in the way she took up space without apologizing quite as much. And when Robin moved aside to let an old aunt armed with a camcorder squeeze through, the denim hugged her hips in a way that made Nancy’s thoughts stumble.
It wasn’t a “neutral” observation. It was appreciation. A slow bite, internal.
Nancy looked away too late, like she’d been caught with her hand in a candy jar.
Robin lifted her head. Their eyes met.
Robin’s smile appeared immediately. Wide, honest, a little too bright, as if simply seeing Nancy in an ordinary place pleased her so much it was almost indecent. And Robin crossed the crowd in a zigzag, apologizing to people who hadn’t asked for it, talking too fast under her breath, like she was narrating her own route to keep herself calm.
When she reached Nancy, she slowed. A micro-pause. The silent question: are we allowed?
Nancy didn’t think. She set her hand on Robin’s forearm, just above the wrist. An anchor point. A gesture that said: you’re real.
Her skin was warm.
Robin glanced down at the hand, then looked back up at Nancy with an expression caught between emotion and a joke she didn’t dare make.
“Hi, Wheeler.”
“Hi, Buckley.”
It was stupid, those last names. Their old armor. It sounded almost normal.
Robin inhaled, like air had texture. “You… wow. You too, you’ve… uh…” She gestured vaguely at Nancy’s head, unable to find a word without getting trapped by what it would imply.
Nancy felt a flicker of laughter. “My haircut?”
Robin made a small grimace of confession. “Your haircut. Like… you could call a senator and terrorize him over the phone.”
Nancy lifted an eyebrow. “Thanks?”
“It’s a compliment. A super compliment. It’s… sexy, okay? No, wait, I mean, it’s… powerful. Very… Boston.”
The word “sexy” dropped between them like a coin on tile. Not loud enough to cause a scene. Loud enough to make the air vibrate.
Nancy felt heat creep up her neck. Robin blinked a second too long, as if she’d surprised herself.
“I…,” Robin rushed on, too fast, “I mean, you look… good. Different. Like. You know.”
Nancy stared at her, and realized Robin was really looking at her. Not “I’m scanning to see if you’re alive,” not “I’m doing the performance of normal.” A focused, almost hungry look, like Robin was taking mental notes of every detail.
Which, obviously, forced Nancy to notice Robin even harder.
The hair fell against her clavicle. A strand caught at the corner of her mouth when she spoke, like it was insisting on being bitten. Her t-shirt was simple, but it followed her better than before. The hips, yes. The ass, yes. That regained roundness that wasn’t “decorative” at all, only: I came back to my body.
Nancy hated the way her stomach tightened.
Robin, as if she’d caught the shift in Nancy’s eyes, tipped her head.
“So,” she said, her voice taking that falsely light tone that hides big things, “how are the… babes at Emerson?”
It came out with insolent ease. Not aggressive. Just… sharp. A small, shining knife.
Nancy stayed still for half a second.
And the worst part was, it wasn’t only the word “babes” that hit. It was that Robin said it to her. Like a test. Like an invitation. Like Robin had put a hand on a door and was waiting for Nancy to push it open.
Nancy swallowed.
“Oh… uh…” She heard her own voice, and she hated how vulnerable it sounded. “I wouldn’t know.”
Robin blinked. “Sorry?”
“I left Emerson,” Nancy said, firmer this time, as if punishing herself for trembling. “I… have a job. Well, an internship. Boston Herald.”
Robin’s face lit up with immediate, brutal joy, almost emotional. She made a small sound, not quite a laugh, not quite a sigh.
“No!” Then, lower, like it was a delicious secret: “I knew it.”
Nancy arched a brow. “You knew it?”
Robin made a vague gesture, palms up. “I know things. Things about… you. Nancy Wheeler doesn’t sit still while the world is on fire. Even when the world stops burning, you… you look for the ashes.”
It was beautiful. And too true.
Nancy felt her throat tighten, so she swerved the conversation the way you swerve a truck.
“And you? Smith?”
Robin gave a crooked smile. “Yeah. Smith. I know, I know. It’s very ‘I’m going to write a thesis on how women are treated in shark movies.’ But it’s good. It’s… calm. Calm-ish. Nobody tries to lock me in a bunker. That’s progress.”
Nancy smiled. Then she realized her hand was still on Robin’s forearm.
She hadn’t pulled it away.
And Robin hadn’t moved away.
Instead, Robin had left her arm there, offered, quiet, as if this touch was something normal, permitted. As if their bodies remembered a language their mouths still refused to speak.
Around them, everyone else stirred: photos, hugs, parents. A fog of normal.
Robin leaned a little closer so Nancy could hear her.
“I thought you’d be… somewhere else,” she said softly. “Not geographically. Like… somewhere else in your head.”
Nancy felt her heart speed up.
“I was,” she admitted.
“And now?”
Nancy looked at Robin. Her blue eyes were clear and tired and sharp all at once, like a flame that survived the rain and doesn’t care anymore about being pretty.
Nancy inhaled. “Now, I’m trying to be… here.”
Silence settled between them like a hand.
Robin swallowed. Then, with an almost tender clumsiness, she blurted:
“Okay, so. Question. Very important. Ultra serious.”
“What?”
Robin made a small grimace, like she was deliberately exposing herself. “Do you… do you realize that when you look at me like that, I… I completely lose the thread?”
Nancy felt a hot jolt in her chest.
“How am I looking at you?”
Robin let out a nervous laugh. “Like you’re… a journalist and I’m a story. Like you’re deciding whether you’re going to publish me.”
Nancy felt her cheeks heat up, and she hated that Robin, again, had put words on something Nancy was trying to hide.
“I’m not…”
Robin cut her off, lower. “Nancy. I’m kidding. A little. But not that much.”
Nancy’s eyes slid, despite her, to Robin’s mouth. The strand of hair. The curve of her smile. Her breathing.
Robin followed that look. Her lips parted, just slightly, as if her body answered before her brain.
Nancy had an image, violent and simple: her hand in Robin’s hair, tugging gently to pull her closer.
She forced herself to breathe.
“Robin…”
The name came out like a promise.
Robin went still. Then she moved, barely. A step that wasn’t a step. Distance reduced by gravity.
And then, somewhere behind them, Steve shouted “PHOTO!” like life had decided to throw a stone into their bubble.
Robin pulled back by a millimeter. Not far. Just enough that the only contact left was Nancy’s hand still on her arm.
But that millimeter was a confession: we were right there.
Robin blinked, caught her breath, put her humor-mask back on too fast, too bright.
“Okay,” she said. “Photo. Yes. Normal. We’re adults. We do photos. Great.”
Nancy let out a small, strangled laugh.
They rejoined the group. They smiled. They posed. Normal played its role.
But every time Robin turned her head, her hair caught the light, and Nancy felt like she’d been slapped softly. Every time Nancy moved, Robin tracked her, as if she’d learned her presence by heart.
And when the crowd finally thinned, when the parents left, when the younger ones drifted off laughing toward a party that would be too loud, Nancy found herself walking beside Robin without anyone having “decided” anything.
The sky was violet. Hawkins smelled like warm earth and memories that refuse to die.
Robin slipped her hands into her pockets. “You know… I thought about you. A lot.”
Nancy looked at her.
Robin stared at the ground, then dared to lift her eyes. “Not in a… uh, I mean, yes, sometimes in a… anyway. I mean, you were… you were the only person I could talk to in my head without getting tangled up.”
A shiver ran over Nancy’s arms.
“Me too,” she said, simply.
Robin slowed. Nancy slowed too.
Their shoulders brushed, almost accidental contact. Neither of them moved away.
Robin exhaled, a very small laugh. “Do you realize how ridiculous this is?”
“What?”
“That we survived… everything.” Robin made a vague gesture at the whole world. “And now I’m terrified of… walking next to you.”
Nancy felt her stomach tighten, but this time she didn’t try to run from the feeling.
“Me too,” she murmured.
Robin stopped. Nancy stopped.
Silence dropped between them, heavier than before, because there was no Steve shouting “photo,” no noise to give them an excuse.
Robin lifted a hand, hesitated, then brushed the tip of her fingers against Nancy’s sleeve. A tiny gesture. Intimate like a confession written in pencil.
“You know,” Robin said, voice rough, “I feel like… your eyes are saying things your mouth refuses.”
Nancy felt her heart hammer.
“And your eyes?” Nancy asked, almost despite herself.
Robin smiled, but it wasn’t the funny smile anymore. It was slow. Conscious. A smile that chooses.
“My eyes,” Robin said, “are doing something very irresponsible.”
Nancy inhaled. Her hand slid from Robin’s forearm down to her hand, slowly, as if asking permission with every millimeter.
Robin let her. Then she closed her fingers.
Their hands fit together like they’d been searching for years.
Nancy felt a deep, hot vertigo that had nothing to do with fear. Something alive. Something simple. Desire.
She lifted her eyes to Robin.
Robin wasn’t joking anymore.
And in that silence, two centimeters from a kiss, Nancy understood why it shook her so badly: because Robin wasn’t only beautiful. Robin had come back. And Nancy, finally, had stopped pretending she didn’t want to touch her.
Robin murmured, barely audible:
“So what do we do with this, Wheeler?”
Nancy tightened her grip.
“We…” She swallowed. “We stop lying.”
Robin closed her eyes for a second, like that sentence landed on her skin.
When she opened them, her smile trembled at the edge of seriousness.
“Okay,” Robin breathed. “Then… come here.”
Nancy didn’t move right away. Not because she didn’t want to. Because she wanted to too much.
Then she stepped forward, slow, and pressed her forehead to Robin’s, a gentle contact, almost adolescent, almost sacred. Robin inhaled, and Nancy felt her breath, warm, close, real.
They stayed like that one second longer than necessary.
Just long enough for the world to change shape.
And when they separated, it wasn’t a retreat.
It was a promise.
The night had that thick blue that makes everything more true. Cars on the road sounded like a distant tide, and Hawkins, for once, didn’t look like a trap. Just a town that slept badly and tried to look normal anyway.
Nancy walked beside Robin. Their hands were still linked, not clenched tight, not like a declaration, more like a thread. A thread you keep between your fingers because you’re afraid everything will vanish if you let it go.
And yet, inside Nancy’s ribcage, something wasn’t pretending.
Her body.
Her body had no patience for careful sentences, for analysis, for “we’ll see,” for “it’s complicated.” It reacted. It flared. A clean, immediate fire, almost insolent, climbing from her belly to her throat every time Robin moved a little too close.
Because Robin walked a certain way now, steadier than before, but still slightly off-beat, like she had to negotiate with her own center of gravity. And every time Robin took a step, Nancy saw the discreet motion of her hips under the denim, the way the fabric tightened, then loosened, then tightened again.
It wasn’t “just” pretty.
It was obsessive.
Nancy tried to focus on something else. On the cracked sidewalk. On the streetlights that hummed. On the graduates’ laughter in the distance. On anything that wasn’t the curve of Robin’s ass, right there, a few centimeters from Nancy’s free hand.
But her thoughts kept coming back. The way a tongue keeps returning to a chipped tooth.
She caught herself imagining, with a clarity that almost hurt, what it would feel like to put her hands on those hips. To feel the heat through the fabric, the solidity returned, the living roundness. Not a vague idea, not a blurry fantasy. A precise image: her fingers anchoring, her palms fitting, her thumbs pressing just enough to say, I’ve got you.
Nancy inhaled a little too hard.
Robin turned her head, attentive. “You okay?”
Robin’s voice was soft, but there was vigilance inside it. The after-war reflex. The reflex of people who learned to read breathing like a weather report.
“Yeah,” Nancy answered, much too quickly. Then, because lying to Robin had always been a sport she lost: “I mean… I don’t know.”
Robin slowed. Their hands stayed linked, and that slowing put Robin half a step ahead, enough for Nancy to see even more. The angle. The light. The silhouette. Like the universe had decided to torture her with elegance.
Robin tipped her head, a strand of her long hair sliding against her cheek. “What’s going on in your head, Wheeler?”
A shiver ran along Nancy’s neck. The way Robin said her last name with that softness made Nancy want to do irresponsible things.
She searched for the “correct” answer. An answer that wouldn’t crack the moment open. An answer that wouldn’t betray the fire.
But the truth was there, huge, animal, impossible to fold into polite little phrases.
So Nancy said nothing. She only stared at Robin’s mouth a fraction of a second too long, and she felt her own body react like someone had brushed her skin.
Robin noticed. Of course she noticed.
A silence settled, not empty, but saturated. Heavy with everything they hadn’t said for years. Heavy with this new closeness, adult, conscious, no longer protected by the excuse of adolescence.
Robin swallowed, and her smile appeared, but not the clown’s. A slower smile, more hesitant, almost dangerous.
“Okay,” Robin murmured, “so it’s that kind of ‘I don’t know.’”
Nancy closed her eyes for a second, like she was gathering courage. When she opened them, it felt like her whole body was glowing under her skin.
“I’m looking at you,” she said, and her voice dipped on the word as if she’d confessed a crime.
Robin blinked. “Yeah, that, I… noticed.”
Nancy let out a brief, nervous laugh, then forced herself to go on, because if she stopped she’d back away. And backing away meant becoming the old Nancy again, the one who choked on her own truth.
“I’m looking at you,” she repeated, lower, “and I… I can’t stop.”
Robin didn’t move. But her breathing changed. A tiny hitch. A signal.
“Why?” Robin asked, almost inaudible.
The question was simple. And brutal. Because Nancy knew exactly why.
Her throat tightened, and instead of answering with words, she let her free hand drift, very slowly, toward Robin’s side. She didn’t touch yet. She only brought it closer, like you bring a match toward a flame to see if it’s dangerous.
Robin watched the hand. Then she lifted her eyes to Nancy, still, attentive, giving permission without saying it.
Nancy finally set her palm on Robin’s hip.
The contact went through Nancy like a hot charge. Not electric, not sharp. Dense, immediate fire climbing back into her belly. The denim was rough under her fingers, but Robin’s heat came through anyway, like her skin had its own light.
Nancy inhaled, and her thumb moved without her meaning to, a tiny motion, an accidental caress.
Robin’s breath went shorter.
“Ah,” Robin said, very low. Then, like she realized she’d spoken: “Uh. Sorry. It’s just that… okay.”
Nancy felt her body flare hotter. It was ridiculous how powerful it was. One hand on a hip and her mind turned to smoke.
Because that hip under her hand wasn’t a concept. It was Robin. Robin alive. Robin back. Robin solid. And Nancy wanted, suddenly, fiercely, to hold her the way you hold something precious and fragile at the same time.
She squeezed a little. Not hard. Just enough to feel the shape. Just enough to anchor herself.
Robin closed her eyes for a fraction of a second, then opened them with a look that wasn’t “funny” at all. A bare look, even fully dressed. A look that said: I understand exactly what you’re doing.
Nancy felt her heart pound.
“You…” Robin started, voice rougher, “you’re doing that on purpose?”
Nancy had no clever answer.
So she told the truth, simple and brutal: “Yes.”
The word fell, and the silence after it was almost a kiss.
Robin let out a trembling laugh, a small sound that felt like an admission. “Okay. Wow. Alright.”
Nancy didn’t pull her hand away. She let it slide a little farther back, just a little, toward the roundness she’d been staring at the whole time. She didn’t grab yet. She only felt, at her fingertips, the curve, the density, the presence. And her body answered, all of it, as if something in her had finally woken up after months of ice.
She caught herself imagining, very clearly, what it would be like to hold Robin’s ass in her hands during a kiss. To have Robin pressed against her, to dare, to apply pressure, to feel Robin tense and then soften. It wasn’t a “dirty” image. It was hungry. It was a soft kind of possession, an admitted want.
Nancy’s breathing sped up.
Robin stared at her, lips parted, like she was imagining too. Like she was carrying images she no longer had the strength to turn into jokes.
“What are you thinking about?” Robin asked.
Nancy wanted to run. Then she remembered her own sentence: we stop lying.
She swallowed. “You,” she said.
Robin rolled her eyes, reflex sarcasm, but her cheeks reddened and her smile went almost disarmed. “So specific, Wheeler.”
Nancy stepped closer. Robin didn’t step back.
“You,” Nancy repeated, softer, “and… what I want to do.”
Robin blinked, and her humor cracked a little. “And… what do you want to do?”
The fire climbed higher. Nancy felt her fingers close, more firmly this time, on the curve behind Robin’s hip. Not violent, not an attack. Certain. Possessive. Clear: I want you. She felt the shape under her palm and her body reacted like she’d thrown herself into cold water, a full-body shiver, a hot vertigo.
Robin’s breath trembled. Her shoulders dropped by a millimeter, like she gave in to something.
Nancy lifted her eyes to her. “This,” she whispered.
Robin stayed still, then very slowly placed her free hand on Nancy’s wrist, not to remove it. To keep it there. To hold it in place.
“Okay,” Robin breathed. “Okay. So… we’re doing this.”
Nancy let out a strangled laugh. “I guess we are.”
Robin shook her head, hair sliding over her shoulders. “It’s… very you, going from ‘journalist mode’ to ‘hands on hips’ with zero transition.”
Nancy smiled, but her eyes stayed serious. “I think I’ve spent my whole life making transitions. Here, I…” She cut herself off, unable to finish without shaking.
Robin murmured: “Here, you what?”
Nancy stepped closer again. They were so close Nancy could smell Robin, simple and clean, a little shampoo, a little skin. Nancy felt her head spin.
“Here,” she said, “I don’t want to pretend anymore.”
Robin closed her eyes for a second, like the words made her dizzy.
When she opened them, her gaze was burning, but gentle. A look that asked without demanding.
“You want… to kiss me?” Robin asked, barely audible.
Nancy felt her body answer before her mouth. A yes in her stomach. A yes in her gripping fingers. A yes in her throat.
But she hesitated anyway. Not from lack of desire. From fear of everything it meant.
Robin watched her hesitate, and her voice turned softer, almost protective.
“Hey,” she said. “You don’t have to. I… I can handle a lot, but I don’t want you to do this if you’re going to hate yourself after.”
Something split open inside Nancy. The old Nancy, the one who punished herself for every deviation. The one who survived by controlling everything.
She pulled Robin a little closer by the hip, as if proving she was there.
“I’m not going to hate myself,” Nancy said, steadier than she expected. Then, lower: “I’m… probably going to lose my mind.”
Robin let out a small trembling laugh, and her fingers tightened around Nancy’s wrist like she was holding on.
“That,” Robin said, “is the most reassuring thing you’ve ever said to me in my entire life.”
Nancy breathed out, almost a laugh. Then she tilted her head, slowly, very slowly, giving Robin time to move away if she wanted.
Robin didn’t move away.
Instead, Robin leaned in by a millimeter, then another, and their lips finally met.
It wasn’t a dramatic kiss. Not a Hollywood explosion. It was warm, real, and it surprised Nancy with its simplicity, like everything she’d held back for years loosened all at once.
Nancy felt Robin’s mouth open slightly under hers, a silent sigh slipping between them. And Nancy, without thinking, brought her other hand up too, gripping more fully now, holding Robin by the hips and that curve behind, as if she needed to feel her completely to believe it was real.
Robin shivered against her, and the kiss changed, deepened, grew heavier, hungrier. Robin made a small, muffled sound that sent the fire in Nancy’s belly climbing even higher.
Nancy squeezed, gently but surely, the way she’d imagined. Her fingers anchored, and she felt Robin press closer, drawn by the gesture, like it gave her permission to let go.
Nancy felt like she was burning.
Not only with desire. With need. With relief too. Like her body was finally saying: yes. There. That. That’s what it was from the beginning.
Robin pulled back for a second, forehead to forehead, lips shining, eyes a little lost.
“Okay,” Robin breathed, voice broken. “Okay, so… wow.”
Nancy, panting, let out a nervous laugh. “Sorry.”
Robin’s eyes went wide. “Don’t be sorry. Don’t be… sorry, Nancy.”
And Nancy, still shaking, still on fire, pulled Robin a little closer by the hips, unable to stop herself.
“I’m not sorry,” she murmured.
Robin smiled, slow, like she’d just heard the most beautiful sentence in the world.
“Then,” she said, very softly, “kiss me again.”
Nancy didn’t need to be asked.