Actions

Work Header

For Better or For Worse

Summary:

Robby's best friend, Ren, is a humanitarian trauma nurse with a deployment packing list where her heart should be. She's done four continents, twelve countries, and one city she never planned to stay in.

He's done thirty years of holding a trauma floor together and exactly zero things about his feelings for her. They're each other's favorite person and for two people who treat commitment like a biohazard, that's as good as it gets.

Then her visa comes into question and she's at risk of not just leaving the country but his life for forever.

So Robby, to the surprise of them all, proposes the greatest commitment of all... marriage.

OR

Robby can only picture one woman next to him for the rest of his life. The Canadian government has opinions about this. Robby has decided the Canadian government can go fuck themselves.

Chapter 1: (Prologue) Your Oxygen Mask and Mine

Notes:

All the best friendships start somewhere right?

CW: Rooftop scene is included in this first chapter

Chapter Text

After spending 10 consecutive years with Médecins Sans Frontières, Serena Demarius had a system for new places.

You learned the exits first.

Then the terrain.

Then the people — not their names, which came automatically, but the shapes of them, the way they moved through a space and what that movement told you before a single word had been exchanged.

You let them call you "Ren" instead of Serena or Demarius so they had an illusion of closeness to you. You do not to get attached.

You move the fuck on.

She had developed this system somewhere around her third deployment and refined it across a decade of living out of a bag in places that required knowing which direction was out, and it had served her reliably in four countries and one continent and a field hospital in a city she did not name, where the generator ran hot and the air tasted faintly of diesel underneath everything else.

She applied it to the Pitt the same way she'd applied it everywhere.

The north wing and the south wing. The elevator on the left that ran slow. The supply corridor that thinned the noise enough to say things in a register that didn't carry. The marble columns in the main hall — too architectural for a basement emergency room, too considered, borrowed from some earlier version of the building that had been something else before it became this.

She would admit to having looked those pillars up online. Once, quietly, in the way she did things she didn't want anyone to know she was curious about. She found what she needed, filed it away and did not make any effort to think about it again.

Ren was good at the Pitt.

And not to be too arrogant, but Ren was good at everywhere.

But as all humans should know, being good at a place was not the same as belonging to it. Ren had learned this distinction early enough that she no longer had any problem with confusing the two.

That was the structure of her life up to now. You learned the terrain. You did the work. You moved on when the work was done. This was the architecture of it — clean, functional, reliable. She had been building it for twenty years and she did not examine the foundation.

She was seven months in and for once in her life there was no viable exit in sight. But Ren was not going to open that folder.

She was going to do the work.

But here was the thing about the work, today. Unlike her colleagues: It was not the worst thing she'd ever seen.

She would think about that later — the way she always thought about the things she couldn't think about anywhere outside of the interim.

She would sit with this very fucked up fact, when the day was finally behind her, that sixty-three victims in the first two hours and then more and then more had not been the worst thing she'd ever been in.

The fucked up fact that when she had moved through bay after bay for fifteen hours she had gone into full machine mode, assessing and triaging and deciding, and that machine had not hesitated once. Not when the floor smelled the way floors smelled during mass casualty events. Not when the count climbed and the bays filled and the only math that mattered was the math of who could still be saved. Not when Abbott had clamped off his own blood line and handed it over and she had taken it and used it without blinking — just noted the volume, registered the resource, moved forward.

She knew, abstractly, that this was useful.

She had also understood for a long time that it was also not entirely healthy — that the places she had been to and the things she had absorbed and the decade of other people's worst days she had walked through had built something in her that was not quite like other people's something. She had built the machine. The machine worked. She had stopped asking what the building cost because that was not a useful question when there were patients in front of her.

She was useful.

She was very good at being useful.

Today, she had been useful in a way that would take weeks to fully account for, and she had not blinked, and she had not stopped, and she had held and triaged and moved through this entire building like the floor was nothing, like the smell was nothing, like the specific and particular horror of what had happened at a music festival in her city on a Tuesday afternoon was simply the next terrain to be learned. She had been useful in the way she was always useful, by stripping the non-essentials and being the machine they needed.

She knew it was fucked up.

She knew it the way she knew the slow elevator and the draft in bay four — a fact about herself, filed, not examined. She was good at the ugly work. She had always been good at the ugly work. She had stopped wondering what that said about her somewhere around year four of moving through the ugliest places on earth and coming out the other side with clean hands and a steady pulse.

This was not the worst thing she'd ever seen.

She would tell no one this. It was not a thing you told people. Because they'd think silently to themselves, 'you are a fucking freak.'

A thought that would pass through Ren's mind in the interim.

Her eyes wandered to the other side of the Pitt, scanning the area and taking stalk. That was when she spotted him. Admittedly, she had been watching him obliquely all day.

It's important to note, that was not a habit Ren had with other people. In fact, she was starting to categorize it as a bad habit, one of her worse ones in fact.

She had colleagues she was fond of — Dana, whose dry patience she respected the way she respected well-maintained equipment; Samira, who had refused the lighter version of her so early and so plainly that Ren hadn't had a chance to make the substitution; Jack, who she would never tell this to, who would make it insufferable if she did, but who had shown up to things, quietly and consistently, in the specific way of people who didn't announce their loyalty because they considered it self-evident.

She watched all of them the way she watched everything — peripherally, practically, the way you kept the terrain updated when you needed to know where everything was.

However, when Ren's eyes found Dr.Robby- it was different, and she had not figured out precisely why.

But she watched him.

Out of the corner of her eye, mostly. The way he managed the floor — the quality of his attention, which was different from other attendings she'd worked under, less about authority and more about presence, the way the room organized itself around him without him appearing to try. The way he talked to patients. The way he talked to his residents.

He was not, she had assessed professionally and early, a remarkable physician by any standard she would apply. Ren had worked under remarkable physicians in some of the hardest conditions on earth. He was good. He was not remarkable.

And still, she watched him anyway.

Ren had developed a strange fondness for Dr. Robby in their time as colleagues,

He was nosy into her life in a way she had expected to find irritating and instead found, somewhat against her will, mildly funny. He was bothersome asked questions no one else thought to ask. They were not the clinical ones or the professional ones, which she deflected easily and automatically.

They were instead the sideways ones, the ones that arrived at an angle before she could see them coming.

Why didn't she have pictures on her walls? Why didn't she know how to buy a bed — 'a bed, Demarius, not a cot, an actual bed, you've been sleeping on a cot for seven months.' Why hadn't she been to Primanti Brothers, did she have a philosophical objection to sandwiches specifically, or was it—

This man was senselessly bothersome and Ren had, in general, implemented a very good deflection system.

But Robby walked around it with the comfortable persistence of a man who either hadn't noticed it was there or had noticed and found it interesting rather than insurmountable.

She had found herself, more than once, answering questions she hadn't planned to answer, in the supply corridor or the break room or at 12:15 over terrible coffee and a chart neither of them was really reading.

Ren didn't give him the real things. She never gave anyone the real things. But she had given him the selected things, the ones she offered people when she wanted them to feel trusted, and he had received them without ceremony and then asked something else the next time, and she had found, gradually, that she was giving him slightly more selected things than she usually gave people.

She had filed this under temporary.

Under he's persistent and it's easier to give a little than to resist completely.

Under he wants to be friends. Best to pretend you'll let him try

But the weeks went by and suddenly Ren was standing here and with only a fraction of a doubt, she might admit to herself that... well yes... Dr. Robby was indeed her friend.

She could now this without hesitation, which itself was a thing she had not fully accounted for.

He had become her friend before she'd decided to let him. Ren, who did not accumulate people, who had built her entire life around warmth-without-rootedness. Ren, who gave people the selected things and kept everything else behind a door that had been locked for so long she'd stopped noticing the lock.

Somehow had gotten in anyway, sideways, through questions about beds and picture frames and sandwich preferences, and she had let him because he made her laugh in the supply corridor and because he was, underneath all the management and the attending and the speech-giving, a person she found she could tolerate in a way she found very few people tolerable.

He was her friend.

And across the Pitt, she could see him breaking... fracturing at the seams.

She had been watching it, peripherally, all day. Dr. Robby was not, what Ren would account, someone who was good at hiding things. Today had been bad for everyone. For Robby it had been a particular kind of bad. Dana had mentioned something about 'the anniversary' underneath the mass casualty underneath the thing with Jake and Leah, the specific layering of griefs that required each loss to sit on top of all the previous ones, compounding. 

Ren was usually good at turning a blind eye to other people's compounding griefs.

She had a system for that too. You focused on your patients. You secured your own mask. You did not drain yourself maintaining vigil over people who were not your immediate responsibility. The airplane instructions were very clear on this: put your own mask on before assisting others.

Ren had spent twenty years being good at the first part. She had been less practiced at the second, and she had made a considered amount of peace with this.

The reasoning was quite simple. You could not be the person who ran toward every worst thing on the planet and simultaneously be the person who absorbed every casualty and wounded comrade. She had made a choice about which kind of person to be and she had made it early and she had not revisited it since.

But now she stood at the back of the hallway and watched him give the speech as the clocked ticked towards the end of shift.

He was standing

"Each of you rose to the occasion." His voice breaking on the "I-" before "can't tell you how proud I am of all of you." The specific honesty of a man who had used up everything he had for performance and was down to the plain version of things. "This place will break your heart. But it is also full of miracles, and that is a testament to all of you coming together and doing what we do best." A pause. "None of us are going to forget today — even if we really, really want to."

And then he walked away.

She watched him go.

And she felt it. It was a the thing she did not have a name for, the thing she had been filing under temporary and it doesn't mean anything and pretend you'll let him try — she felt it in the specific way you felt things that lived below the machine, in the part of you that the protocols couldn't reach. She watched him walk toward the stairwell and she thought: he should not be alone.

She stood there.

She thought about the airplane instructions.

She thought about how she never bothered with the second part.

She thought, very quietly, in a part of herself that did not consult the rest of her before speaking: Someone should help him put his mask on.

She did not know what to do with that.

But her brain had already stopped thinking and started moving.

Her feet moved faster than she'd intended. Not running (she would not call it running) but not walking the way she usually walked either, which was efficient, economical, the pace of someone who knew where she was going and was managing the distance sensibly. This was different. This was the pace of someone who needed to arrive before something closed. She pushed through the stairwell door and she went up, and she did not think about why Michael Robinavitch had her climbing stairs at 9PM at the end of the worst shift she'd seen outside of a deployment.

She did not think about the particular tightness in her chest as she climbed. There was something beating in her chest. It was partly urgency and partly something she didn't think she was capable of finding a name for.

She did not think about the why, of all the people she had watched walk away from all the worst shifts in all the places she had been, it was him that had her feet moving before the rest of her had finished the argument.

She thought: roof.

She went faster.


When she finally shoved open the door to roof access, she found him on the wrong side of the railing.

The cold air blasted against her face like a bucket of cold water. It stopped her in her tracks. Not long, but long enough to run the assessment before she could stop herself. She assessed the way he was standing. The quality of the stillness. How close to the edge. How his head was angled, not taking in the view. Not standing at the railing.

On the other side of it, in the strip of concrete between the metal and the drop, in the way that was not casual, in the way that meant something. In the way she had been trained to recognize and now recognized with the flat clarity of a body that had understood before she had.

She spotted the stethoscope that was looped over the railing beside him.

Ren's breath caught in her throat. She walked toward him. Even. Unhurried. The way you approached a deer you did not want to startle.

"Didn't take you for the brooding type, Robinavitch." A discordant note dropped into the silence.

He didn't turn. He was looking at the city, or at the dark above it, or at something that existed entirely on the other side of both. He had the particular quality of a man whose gaze had turned inward and found, there, a ledger he was not winning. His shoulders were wrong. His whole body was wrong, the posture of someone who had been holding something for a very long time and had simply, finally, run out of the mechanics of holding.

She stopped on the roof-side of the railing. A few feet from him.

She looked at his profile in the city light. The tears on his face that he wasn't managing — because there was no one to manage them for. The stethoscope. The drop beyond it.

"That was a good speech," she said finally.

He made a sound. Not a laugh. The shape of one, emptied out.

He shook his head once. A slow, definitive, the motion of a man contradicting something he is tired of being told.

"No," he said. "It wasn't." His voice sounded like that of a man who had run out of the register that performed being all right. "I broke." He said it like a diagnosis — flat, without inflection, naming a fact he was not going to perform being okay about. "I shut down. The moment everybody needed me the most — I wasn't there." A pause. The city below going on without caring about either of them. "I needed to be a machine." He looked at her for the first time, briefly, and away. "Like you. Emotionless, cold- no hesitation. I needed to just — run the protocols and not—"

"Stop," she said, a thrum of panic running in her chest at the prospect of letting him spiral further. Her voice coming out harsher than she meant to.

He went still. Ren looked at the shadow of his back. The loneliness held in his shoulders like Atlas at the end of the world.

Her eyes flickered to the railing. To the stethoscope on it. To the two feet of concrete between him and the drop.

It's important to note now, that Ren hates heights.

This was not a mild preference or a vague general discomfort. It was a physical fact about her body. It felt like a wrongness that started in her inner ear and spread outward, the way the ground became provisional and unreliable when there was nothing between her and a long way down, the tightening in her chest that was not metaphorical. She had managed it competently for 22 years by not putting herself in positions that required managing it. And she was, in general, a person who knew her exits and used them. Who was practiced at the first part of the airplane instructions and unbothered by the gap.

But looked at Robby on the wrong side of the railing. She looked at how lonely he was on the wrong side of the railing... and she stepped through.

The air on this side was the same temperature. Pittsburgh was the same distance below. Nothing had changed except the two inches of metal now behind her, and her body, which had registered this before the action was complete and was now producing a comprehensive and extremely persuasive argument involving every available sensory channel.

But breathed through it and she was determined to stand next to him.

Robby, for his part, had gone completely still. She could feel it. The shift in his attention, sudden and total, the quality of a room changing when someone walks in. He was looking at her out of the corner of his eye. She felt it without turning her head, in the peripheral way she had been feeling things about him for seven months. She kept her eyes on the Pittsburgh skyline and breathed through what her body was doing and did not look down.

She was shaking like a fucking leaf but she was doing her best not to let it show.

"If you had been a machine today," she said, and her voice came out even, her jaw steeled in a mental vice grip of willpower, "if you had run fifteen hours of that without cracking — without the voice breaking in the speech, without the moment in the morgue, without any of it—" she paused— "that's when I would have worried about you."

He said nothing, looking over at her with tears glistening in his eyes. She went on.

"We..." She paused. "We can't do this job as machines. Not the real version of it. The protocols are machines. The triage system is a machine. That's not us." She was looking at the river, at the lights breaking on it in long, scattered lines. "We're the reason the machine runs. And it runs because we care. Because we have to care." A beat. "The day you stop caring is the day you become a liability."

The pause held.

"There's a story," she said. She said it differently — quieter, careful, the voice she used for things that were real rather than performed.

She felt him wait. She had noticed that about him, in seven months of supply corridors and 12:15 lunches — that he knew how to wait. He knew how to listen.

"About disaster," she said. "It was kind that doesn't leave a before and an after — just an after. Just like today. It was a day were everything changed at once. A child of millions, stuck in the middle of it. The kid has lost everything by the time it's over. All of it, the whole shape of her life." A pause, her teeth threatening to shiver but not from the fear this time. "But there's an emergency aid. Not by accident." She stopped, and then continued, quieter: "And she stays. Through all of it. And the child asks her, eventually, why she came back. Why she stays." She paused. "Because someone has to be there. On the worst day of someone's life. Someone has to be the person who is there."

The city went on below them.

"There are a 106 who are still breathing tonight," Ren said. The evenness in her voice was costing her more now; she did not stop paying it. "106 who are going to spend the rest of their lives knowing that someone was there on their worst day." She looked at him. "They are going to thank whatever diety they pray to... That you, Robinavitch. You were there."

He was looking at her now.

The full weight of his attention, turned toward her now and fully present, the way he was present when he was present, which was completely, without remainder. His eyes on her with a shine in them that she did not have a place for. Something that was looking at her very specifically and she was shaking like a fucking leaf.

She was not entirely sure anymore whether it was the heights.

Suddenly his hand found hers with a snap.

He didn't reach so much as arrive as just grip her. The motion nearly incidental, the way someone's hand found a railing in the dark. His hand, warm, closing around hers on the wrong side of a railing at 9PM at the end of the worst shift she'd seen outside a war zone.

She went still.

Not the stillness of surprise. The stillness of all the wind in the world once very loud going quiet all at once.

He had turned back to the city — she could feel it in the angle of him, the slight turn of his face away — and his hand was in hers and neither of them spoke and Pittsburgh went on without caring about either of them. His grip tightening on her hand like an anchor keeping him stilled on the wrong end of the railing.

The shaking eased in her bones all at once.

"I guess that makes you the person," he said. Quiet, rough at the edges, more careful than his normal voice. "The one who shows up. On someone's worst days."

She looked at him. A flicker of confusion and clarity shining in her eyes, because in all of Ren's dishonesty, she couldn't for sure say that's who she was on this railing. If she was simply someone who came up on his worst day. Did she simply come up her to be that person... a person... his... person?

She felt the truth land somewhere below the machine, below the system, below the architecture she had built and maintained and lived inside of for twenty years.

"Not always," she whispered. The wind seemed to carry her voice away. 

She said it quietly. It was the truest thing she had said on that rooftop.

That was the bedrock of her whole structure, the thing she had built everything on top of and never put down. But she said it in a different register than usual. Not as a weather report. Not as the fact she usually made of it, clean and declarative. As something smaller. As a question- that for once in her life, she was unsure of the answer.

Ren squeezed his hand. It came from somewhere below truth. Below the part of her that had stopped at the back of the hallway and made the airplane argument and lost. Right below the truth of why she had rushed up her to the rooftop.

She heard Robby exhale as he squeezed back.

After a breath. The door banged open.

Abbott came through it with the direct, assessing energy of a man who knew exactly where he'd find what he was looking for and had decided to go find it. He took in the railing. The stethoscope. The two of them on the wrong side of it. His face did something very small and very controlled. Then he looked at Robby, and his expression settled into something that was not quite a smile but was in the same territory.

"You're in my spot," he said. "Just so you know, Grubhub will not deliver to the roof—" a beat— "but there is a DoorDash guy..."

It was so precisely the wrong register for the moment — so completely, specifically Abbott — that it broke through the thing the night had built around them like a stone through glass.

Robby made a sound she hadn't heard from him before. Unwilled. Real. Something that had been waiting behind all the other sounds all day.

Ren exhaled once, quietly.

Abbott stood on the roof-side of the railing with his hands in his pockets, unhurried. Looking at Robby the way someone looked at a person they had known long enough to understand the shape of their breaking.

"That was a great speech," Abbott said. "I wish I'd given it."

"No, you didn't" Ren said, glancing back at Jack with sidelong huff.

Jack chuckled, "No, I don't"

Robby looked at him. "I broke," he said. A clearer admission this time rather than the tearful truth Ren had received earlier. "In thirteen. I shut down—"

"For a moment," Abbott said. "Seconds. Maybe minutes." He said it simply, without decoration. "And then you didn't." He paused. "You rocked it out there tonight. All of you did." His eyes moved briefly to Ren and then back to Robby. "You know why we keep coming back?"

Robby was quiet. Ren was intrigued by the answer.

"It's in the blood," Abbott said. "Like bees with a hive. We can't not." A beat. "My therapist has thoughts about that."

"Does it help?" Robby said. "The therapist."

Abbott considered this with the seriousness of someone who had actually thought about it. "Kept me from jumping off this roof so far."

Ren glanced over the edge with a shudder, "I think we could all use a visit after this."

Robby looked at him for a long moment. Then he looked at Ren. Then he looked out at the city, at the Pittsburgh skyline doing its indifferent luminous thing.

"Let's shut up," he said, "and get a drink."

"Yes," said Abbott.

"For God's sake please get back on the right side of the railing first," Ren said.

The park was green and ordinary and good.

She had not been to this park. She had passed it. She passed everything eventually, given enough time and the restless radius of a person who needed to know where everything was.

However, she had not stood in it at night with a beer in her hand while the day dissolved around her and the people she had come through it with found themselves here, drawn together by whatever gravity operated on survivors who weren't ready yet to be alone.

Mohan had found her way there, somehow, despite the crying Ren had heard through the bathroom wall an hour ago. She had the look of someone who had done something extraordinary for the first time and was standing on the other side of it, not sure yet of the ground.

Javadi was there too — still in scrubs, with the particular expression of someone who had survived their first day of work in a war zone and had not yet acquired the emotional callus that would make the next one survivable. She looked both older and younger than she had at 7AM.

Ren sat down next to Jack with a beer she was holding more than drinking. 

She watched Robby with a soft smile.

He was talking. She could hear the cadence from where she stood — unpolished, honest, the voice he used when he had run out of everything except the true version of things. Javadi asked him something and he looked at her with the fond exasperation of a man who had been doing this for 20 years and had not stopped finding it worth doing.

"I'd say," he told Javadi, with the dry certainty of someone who had made this calculation and was confident in it, "if she's old enough to put in a test tube and intubate, she's old enough to drink a beer."

Javadi's expression cycled rapidly through several things. Ren identified one of them as panic and another as pride.

Mohan looked like she was filing this for future use.

Ren almost smiled with her teeth.

After a moment, he said: "Nights suit me. My therapist says I find comfort in the dark." He said it without self-pity or apology. As a fact about himself, filed, presented. "Combat medicine. Six years."

Ren looked at Jack with a nod, "MSF. Ten years." Jack turned up his chin and offered Ren a fist bump and in spite of herself, she tapped her first to it.

Robby looked at the prosthetic leg on the bench.

Robby looked at Ren's tired, soft, smile.

He looked at the city.

Something moved through his face — complicated and layered, the expression of a person receiving information they had been close to for a very long time without fully seeing it. The expression of a man who was, maybe, beginning to look at things more directly.

"Huh," he said.

"Yeah," said Abbott.

"The more you know." said Ren.

They sat in the comfortable silence of three people who had a lot of history and had learned exactly how much of it needed to be said out loud.

Ren looked at her beer.

She looked at the street beyond the park, where a siren had started up — faint, growing, the particular register of an ambulance rather than a police car, moving toward the hospital. The group heard it. Heads turned. Robby watched it pass, the lights going by in two sweeps of red and white.

He looked at it for a moment.

"Tomorrow is another day," he said.

Then he stood up, and he gave Ren a look she did not entirely know how to catalogue. Something brief and direct, something that landed in the same place the hand had landed, the same below-the-machine place she did not have a file for.  and he said, quieter, to her specifically: "I could uh..." he paused, scratching the back of his head, "use a friend." She could see the uncomfortable look on his face when he said it.

She finished her beer.

She stood up.

"Yeah," she said.

They walked back.

Abbott with them for a while, and then not, and then it was just the two of them and the Pittsburgh night and the particular quiet of a city winding down, and she fell into step beside him and he didn't ask why and she didn't explain.

It was a townhouse on a block she hadn't been to before. He unlocked it without comment. She followed him in.

A kitchen. A window. The city outside still going. He moved through the space with the quiet automation of someone running familiar routines because the familiar routines were all that were left. She sat on the counter because that was what her body decided to do, and she watched him move.

He found two mugs.

He found the tea.

The right tea — the specific kind, which she registered in the peripheral way she registered things she wasn't ready to think about. She watched him set it beside hers on the counter with the quiet certainty of a man who had done this before, or who had imagined it enough times that the motion had worn a groove. She did not ask how he knew.

He set the mug in front of her.

She wrapped both hands around it.

Outside, Pittsburgh went on without either of them, which was the reliable thing about it, the thing she had always found comforting about cities.

They didn't need you.

She sat in his kitchen at the end of the worst shift in her recent history and she held the mug with both hands. Her body was still in machine mode or she was telling herself she was, which had always been the same thing and which was, tonight, for the first time in twenty years, beginning to feel like this was a bad distinction.

The crash was weighing on her mind.

She thought about a decade of worst days walked through with clean hands and a steady pulse. About a blood bag handed over without hesitation. About sixty-three in the first two hours and the machine not blinking, not once. She thought about the fact that this was not the worst thing she had ever seen, and that she could not tell anyone this, and that she had been carrying that particular aloneness for so long that she had stopped noticing its weight.

She thought about a hand snapping onto hers in the dark.

The tea was the right temperature. She brought it up to her lips and let the calm fall over her face. Robby's eyes trained on the way her eyes closed and submitted to the peace.

Somehow, she held on.

A small laugh tipped off the edge of her lips.

A gift of tea was such a small thing but it felt like someone putting her mask on for her.