Actions

Work Header

object permanence

Summary:

It's exhausting, honestly. Loving someone this much.

Six months of silence, and then Aubrey Hall.

Penelope and Colin are thrown back into each other’s orbit for Kate and Anthony’s wedding, with too much history and not nearly enough distance. Tension simmers, old wounds resurface, and neither of them is as unaffected as they’d like to be.

Notes:

Hi! Hello!! Welcome!!!

We are so excited to finally launch this sucker!!!! We have been working on this for over a year now. It is so special to us because it cemented our bff status both in fandom and in real life, and that friendship and working on this story together have helped us through some of the lowest lows of our personal lives this past year.

Thank you for reading along with us. We hope you enjoy this angsty ride.

x

abvj & lilacsandpoppys

*

Chapter 1: we could have had it all

Chapter Text

FYI: this is the only chapter that is 100% text-based. If you click on the video images, it will take you to the tik-tok videos.

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
20 DEC 2024
[19:51]

Colin: hopeurhavingfun

Colin: Saw your story

Colin: I know it’s a work happy hour but ???? did my invite get lost in the mail??

Colin: Is ELOISE there????

Pen ☀️: lol just come by. Harp & crown by Ben’s weird ex’s house.

Colin: omw to the tube x

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
23 DEC 2024
[08:51]

Pen ☀️: pen-cat

Pen ☀️: spotted on my walk to the tube

Colin: I would die for them fr

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
24 DEC 2024
[15:23]

Colin: When will you be here? I have hidden the maltesers for you, but Greggy is on a mission. Cannot promise how much longer they will remain hidden

Pen ☀️: on my way. Should be there by 430

Pen ☀️: ps i made you more biscuits

Pen ☀️: don’t say I never did anything for you

Pen ☀️: tell your mum I grabbed the extra champagne, please!!!

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
24 DEC 2024
[23:52]

Colin: I can’t sleep

Pen ☀️: why

Colin: i have like a million questions going through my mind

Colin: like will you like my gift

Colin: what did you get me

Colin: if I were a worm, would you still like me?

Colin: Or a snake?

Colin: Basically, what is the threshold for you not liking me anymore? If I was a a spider? Would that be the bar?

Pen ☀️: Depends on the kind, i think

Colin: I would be a nice one. Like charlotte.

Pen ☀️ : Iol of course. Naturally.

Colin: how come noses run but feet smell?

Colin: why is it called chili if it’s hot?

Colin: do you remember what age you stopped believing in Santa?

Colin: I was six, I think. Ant showed me where the presents were hidden. I cried. He laughed. I don’t know that I have forgiven him for this honestly

Pen ☀️: what a fucker

Colin: what does space smell like?

Colin: is the s or c silent in scent

Colin: why can i never remember the proper utilisation of lie vs lay

Pen ☀️: COLIN

Colin: Yes, Pen?

Pen ☀️: It’s midnight. Happy Christmas!

Pen ☀️: meet me by the tree to exchange our presents?

Colin: YES! Be there in 5.

 

______________________________________________________

Pen ☀️to Colin
25 DEC 2024
[10:29]

Pen ☀️: Happy Christmas, I’ve already committed three (3) mental crimes and I haven’t left the house yet

Pen ☀️: Portia has more than outdone herself this year… she has lovingly gifted me a book called “Why Am I Dancing Alone? Here’s how to find and keep someone to love”

Pen ☀️: First of all, I’m very happy dancing alone, thank you very much. Remember Ben’s birthday? Abba? I was showered with compliments

Pen ☀️: I might wrap it back up and re-gift it to her next year. Maybe add a note: “you first.”

Pen ☀️: Ugh. Why does this suck so much

Colin: What the fuck, Pen??? Are you serious??

Colin: Wanna do a celebratory book burning? I’m down. We have a substantial fire pit at Aubrey

Colin: Wait - let me run to my room, call you in a sec

[10:33]

Colin: [Initiated a FaceTime call, 26 minutes and 34 seconds]

[11:46]

Colin: and for the record, you’re already loved

Colin: There is no version of you that even remotely needs a book like that

 

______________________________________________________

Pen ☀️to Colin
26 DEC 2024
[12:23]

Pen ☀️: I’m bored

Pen ☀️: wanna hang?

Colin: omw

Pen ☀️: bring snacks, please!

Colin: duh

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
27 DEC 2024
[20:45]

Colin: [Initiated a FaceTime call, 49 minutes and 37 seconds]

 

______________________________________________________

Pen ☀️to Colin
28 DEC 2024
[21:45]

Pen ☀️: colincasual

Pen ☀️: is this you?

Colin: [Initiated a FaceTime call, 58 minutes and 23 seconds]

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
29 DEC 2024
[20:15]

Colin: spotted in my camera roll

Colin: 5ed93683cdbb6b59664c8e87b627f35c

Pen ☀️: omfg babies

Pen ☀️: is that from uni? God, why do you still have that

Pen ☀️: I look good though. I’m saving it for posterity

Colin: you always look good, Pen

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
31 DEC 2024
[18:17]

Colin: Let me know when you get here. I want to talk to you about something

Pen ☀️: That sounds… ominous

Pen ☀️: make sure you get me a drink first, yeah?

Colin: I’ll have one waiting ;)

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
31 DEC 2024
[22:33]

Colin: where are you

Colin: Pen?

[22:46]

Colin: El said you caught a ride back to yours. Text me when you’re up tomorrow

1 Jan 2025
[00:01]

Colin: Happy New Year, Pen!!!!!!

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️

1 Jan 2025
[08:07]

Colin: meme-1

Colin: this made me laugh

Colin: Good Morning x

Colin: Wanna grab brunch today?

Colin: or are you still recovering?

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
2 Jan 2025
[09:43]

Colin: Moooooorning

Colin: image

Colin: made me think of you. Also, worked up the courage to go back to the café where I read my horrible (deep and meaningful) poetry at that open mic night ages ago. I don’t *think* anyone noticed who I was, but can never be sure. No paps, please

Colin: (To be fair, I was at least 4 pints in)

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
3 Jan 2025
[12:24]

Colin: At this point I can only assume you’ve been either kidnapped or murdered. Thumbs up if you’re ok?

Colin: Btw, at Ben’s and he won’t stop talking about some girl he barely talked to once. He’s bordering on woeful Victorian poet, absolutely insufferable. Send help.

[19:39]

Colin: Hey, if I did something… let me know. Hope you’re ok. Don’t want to flood your messages, but. Can’t help it.

Colin: Miss you x

[23:19]

Colin: no worries if you’re busy. Or overwhelmed. Or all of the above. Totally get it

Colin: Just take care of yourself, Pen x

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Eloise ☠️
4 Jan 2025
[07:01]

Colin: have you heard from Pen? She hasn’t been answering my texts.

Colin: I haven’t seen her since NYE.

Colin: Did something happen with Portia? Pen said she was a real shit at christmas

Colin: Although I guess there is nothing new about that really

Eloise ☠️ to Colin
4 Jan 2025
[11:37]

Eloise ☠️: I have heard from her

Eloise ☠️: she is fine

Colin: can you tell her I’ve been trying to get ahold of her

Eloise ☠️: she knows

Colin: Ok

Colin: wait. No. Not ok. She can’t text me back? Wtf. It doesn’t sound like she is okay

Colin: I am going to head over there

Eloise ☠️: Do not. I repeat: do not do that. She is alive and she is okay

Eloise ☠️: She just needs some space

Colin: from me? Or like in general

Eloise ☠️: Yes.

Eloise ☠️: And she doesn’t know how to say it for herself, so I am saying it for her

Colin: This doesn’t make any fucking sense, eloise just tell me what the fuck is going on

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
4 Jan 2025
[18:25]

Colin: is this because of what happened at the party? Because we kissed?

Colin: fuck, pen. I didn’t mean to make you uncomfortable

Colin: if thats it, we can just forget about it ok? We can just move the fuck on

Colin: I will move on if that is what you want, just fucking talk to me

Colin: please, pen

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
8 Jan 2025
[23:45]

Colin: i leave tomorrow for my next assignment. Are we really not going to talk before I go?

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
12 Jan 2025
[09:13]

Colin: Miami is beautiful. Sunny and hot. It is honestly disgusting. People say it is a "dry heat". Wtf does that even mean? I don't think your hair wouldn't survive regardless, but fuck, you always look so cute when your curls become a mess. It always reminds me of those summers at Aubrey.

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
15 Jan 2025
[21:48]

Colin: blacony

Colin: you used to love this song. must have played it 50x on our way up to aubrey hall that one summer

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
19 Jan 2025
[17:46]

Colin:

Colin: nearly pissed myself at dinner trying not to laugh at this

Colin: you would have been so mad at me for laughing

Colin: wish you were here x

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
14 Feb 2025
[02:59]

Colin: Everything makes me think of you.

Colin: Miss you all the time

Colin: xxx

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
2 MAR 2025
[18:56]

Colin: it’s my birthday today. I thought you’d reach out today.

Colin: happy birthday to myself, I guess

Colin: We haven’t missed each other’s birthdays in twelve fucking years, Pen.

Colin: what the fuck

[22:42]

Colin: clearly you have me blocked

Colin: so fuck it

Colin: I miss you. I miss you so much it fucking hurts. I always miss you.

Colin: Looking back, I realise that should have been my first clue. Even when we were kids, there was hardly a day when you wouldnt cross my mind. Pen would like this. Pen would think this is funny. This reminds me of Pen. It was like you were there with me. And you were, I guess. I always felt like you saw me. Like you knew me. Understood me. I even hoped you loved me - even it was as a friend.

Colin: Is knowing the true me why you pulled away?

Colin: If it is, I guess I can understand that.

Colin: You do deserve the best, Pen.

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
8 APR 2025
[00:01]

Colin: Happy Birthday, Pen

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
26 APR 2025
[15:09]

Colin: I’m sitting in this tiny café in Florence where the espresso is too strong and the chairs are uneven and they’re playing some Italian version of that song you liked last summer. The one you swore was about us even though the lyrics didn’t make any sense.

Colin: God you’d love it here. The waiter called me “signor” like I’m someone important and I just nodded like a fraud. You would’ve laughed. Like really, really laughed.

Colin: I keep trying to experience this place, but it all feels like a story I want to tell you, and you’re not here. So what’s the point?

Colin: I find myself asking that a lot lately. What’s the point without you?

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
5 MAY 2025
[00:01]

Voice Memo [Duration 00:27 secs]

Transcript: Hey. I don’t know what to say in a text anymore. So here’s my voice, I guess. because maybe then it’ll remind you I’m real. I’m still here. Still me. Still… yours, if you want. God, ok. I just miss you. Always miss you. [muffled] you pathetic twat.

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
16 MAY 2025
[10:41]

Colin: Passed two tourists arguing about directions. You used to get like that when we travelled. So stubborn. So certain you knew the “more scenic route,” even if it was just a longer way to get lost.

Colin: I used to follow you, every time. No questions.

Colin: And you’d look back and smirk like you’d won, like I wasn’t just happy to be behind you.

Colin: I’d still follow you. Even though we haven’t talked in ages and I don’t know if we ever will again. I’d follow you anywhere.

Colin: Even if you didn’t want me to.

[13:59]

Colin: Not in a creepy way. Just to be clear.

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
31 May 2025
[15:23]

Colin: It feels weird to be in the same city as you again but not be able to talk to you or see you

Colin: joey-2

Colin: joey-3

Colin: Spotted this little guy. Told him to tell you I said hi.

 

______________________________________________________

Colin to Pen ☀️
4 JUN 2025
[13:04]

Colin: On my way to Aubrey and saw a woman with red hair like you. Nearly followed her until I realised I can’t do that anymore. It’s been so fucking quiet without you

Colin: I keep thinking about what I’ll say to you when I see you. Assuming you’ll be there, obviously. Which you will be. But it’s been so long… I dunno anymore. Can’t trust myself for shit

Colin: I don’t want to ruin the wedding for you. I want to stay out of your way

Colin: But, fuck. I’m fucking desperate Pen

Colin: Hoping beyond hope you give me a chance to explain. That you listen to me. Hear me.

Colin: I’d do anything. You have to know that. I’d do fucking anything.

Colin: anyway. See you at the wedding, Pen