Archive of Our Own

Recent bookmarks

1. Public Bookmark *

   Choose Me Instead by myomantic

   Fandoms: Five Nights at Freddy's, Five Nights at Freddy's (Movie 2023)  

   • Explicit
   • Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings
   • M/M
   • Complete Work

   19 Dec 2025

   Tags

   • Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings
   • Michael Afton/Mike Schmidt
   • Michael Afton
   • Mike Schmidt (Five Nights at Freddy's)
   • Vanessa Shelly (Five Nights at Freddy's Movie)
   • Abby Schmidt (Five Nights at Freddy's Movie)
   • Jeremiah (Five Nights at Freddy's Movie)
   • Charlotte "Charlie" Emily
   • Stalking
   • Obsessive Behavior
   • Non-Consensual Voyeurism
   • Sibling Rivalry
   • Masturbation
   • Movie: Five Nights at Freddy's 2 (2025)
   • Blow Jobs
   • Dubious Consent
   • Michael Afton is a creep
   • Phone Sex
   • Enemies to Lovers
   • Porn with Plot
   • Electrocution
   • Michael Afton is Bad at Feelings
   • Knifeplay
   • this turns into a full blown sappy romance story by the end oops

   Summary

   After the events of the second movie, Michael Afton begins to stalk Mike Schmidt in order to learn more information about his enemy and to develop a new plan for revenge. He ends up seeing more than he expected, and his hatred for Mike transforms into obsessive desire.

   Series

   • Part 1 of Mike x2 Stories

   Language:

   English

   Words:

   42,774

   Chapters:

   8/8

   Comments:

   265

   Kudos:

   1,884

   Bookmarks:

   182

   Hits:

   25,983

   Bookmarked by Ssummerda

   20 Dec 2025