Work Text:
“Hey, Frankie..?” Gerard called out. His voice was an interruption to the silence and voices on the TV in front. Frank glanced at Gerard, the tilt of his head a question.
Gerard’s lips thinned together – he was thinking something. He always does this when he’s going to ask something off-putting.
“Can we like – do something?” Gerard questioned. Then continued, “You can say no, I totally get it ‘cause it’s weird, but… Could we do this thing where you shove either a dildo or your dick up my ass, and I have to guess if it’s real or fake?”
Frank blinked. Gerard talked in large portions, which was well known; it’s just that he’s asking for something odd and sexual.
Gerard noticed the pause.
“Never mind. Forget I said that,” Frank interrupted Gerard with the wave of his hand.
It honestly was tame compared to what Gerard would do if he really felt himself today.
“Yeah.” Frank snorted. “So, how does this work? Elaborate.”
Gerard’s lips twitched into a smirk, and his shoulders stopped tensing up from anxiety.
“Okay. So, as I’ve said, you have to let me guess what you’re putting up my ass. I have to wear a blindfold, and I guess from the sensation,” He explained. Gerard was a little happy Frank didn’t tell him to fuck off.
"Okay... Did you make this up?" Frank asked. he was totally happy to do it; it just made him laugh a little. "I'll go get the stuff..."
Gerard shrugged. "Eh, not really. I read about it online somewhere, and it sounded kinda hot. Plus, I've been wanting to try out some new stuff with you, Frankie."
He smiled slyly at Frank, his hazel eyes glinting with mischief and anticipation. Frank couldn’t help but smile back.
"That's awesome that you're down for it. I really appreciate it," Gerard said sincerely. He knew that many guys probably wouldn't be okay with such an odd and intimate challenge. But Frank has always been cool and open-minded about trying new things together.
Gerard watched as Frank climbed off the couch and headed towards the bedroom. He could hear drawers opening and closing in the distance.
He called out after him playfully, "Make sure you find a nice, big one to really test me with!" Gerard shouted. He smirked and settled back into the couch cushions, waiting patiently for Frank to return.
"Oh, and grab my blindfold too!" Gerard yelled out. He knew he had a black velvet one tucked in his nightstand drawer. Perfect for this little guessing game.
Frank's eyes rolled playfully, and he picked up what they needed. Dildo, Lube, Blindfold, and Frank's own dick. He returned to the room, hiding the dildo behind his back and handing Gerard the blindfold.
"No peaking," Frank said. He sat on the bed, watching as Gerard put the blindfold on.
"Since we're doin' this, lemme undress you," Frank offered. Once Gerard agreed to that, Frank slipped off Gerard's shorts and boxers. And then his black t-shirt. He stepped back to observe Gerard's bare, milky smooth skin. "You're so pretty, you know?"
Gerard blushed at the compliment, his cheeks flushing pink beneath the blindfold.
"Stop it, you jerk," he laughed, swatting playfully at Frank's chest. "I'm not pretty, I'm handsome. There's a difference."
He settled back on the bed, now nude except for the blindfold covering his eyes. The cool air kissed his bare skin, making the fine hairs on his arms and legs stand on end. Gerard's heart raced with anticipation and just a hint of nervousness.
"Okay, I'm ready," Gerard announced. He took a deep breath, trying to calm his nerves. "Remember, be gentle at first. I've never done anything like this before."
He spread his legs slightly, the cool air now caressing his most intimate places. Gerard's cock was already starting to harden, his body reacting eagerly to the promise of pleasure to come. He gripped the bedsheets tightly in his fingers, eagerly awaiting Frank's first touch.
His hazel eyes, though unseen behind the blindfold, were focused on nothing - seeing only the dark velvet fabric and the way his own heart was pounding in his chest. The silence stretched between them, heavy with anticipation and desire.
"Well? Come on, Frankie..." Gerard prodded gently, a shaky smirk on his kissable lips. "Surprise me with your 'surprise'."
Frank laughed as Gerard swatted his chest. Frank slipped into the nude, too, only really covered by his own boxers. He crawled onto the bed.
“Okay— as much as I like seeing your face, I think it’s better if you get on your hands and knees, I think,” Frank said after a beat. “You’re totally gonna know what I’m doing cause your ass isn’t in the air.”
Gerard felt a flicker of nervous excitement at Frank's suggestion. He hesitated for a moment before nodding slowly.
"Okay... yeah, you're probably right," he agreed softly, biting his lower lip. With a deep breath, Gerard flipped over onto his hands and knees on the bed. The cool sheets greeted his chest and knees as he settled into position.
He could feel the vulnerability of being exposed like this, with his ass and cock on full display for Frank. But more than that, he felt a thrill of anticipation, wondering what Frank would do next. Would he use the toy first, or his own hard cock hidden beneath the tent in his boxers?
Gerard's breathing grew heavier, his chest rising and falling more rapidly as he waited. His hazel eyes, though blindfolded, gazed intently into the darkness, focused on detecting any subtle cues of Frank's approach.
The silence stretched between them, broken only by the soft rustling of fabric and their own anticipatory breaths. Gerard's body tingled with goosebumps, his skin prickling with excitement and a hint of nervousness. He gripped the sheets tightly, his knuckles turning white, as he braced himself for the unknown sensation to come.
First, Frank fingered Gerard to get him ready for the big deal. After he was done, he pulled out his fingers.
“Okay. Now you’re ready for this, umm— guess the dick-dildo shit,” Frank said.
He leaned away from Gerard and slicked up something. The wet sounds of lube immediately picked up in Gerard’s ears, and he whined weakly. His face was now shoved deep into the mattress, the blindfold still on. Frank gripped Gerard’s hair and pulled up his head so far his back went into a straight line on his knees. He knew Gerard liked that.
“Anyone home? We still playing that game?” Frank asked with a smirk that Gerard could just hear.
Gerard gasped sharply, his back arching into a perfect straight line as Frank gripped his hair and pulled his head back. The sudden movement made him let out a choked moan, his fingers scrabbling at the sheets.
"Hnngh, yes!" he hissed, his voice strained with anticipation and a hint of pain. "We're still playing, you asshole. Just... just don't break me, okay?"
“Don’t worry, I won’t.” Frank cooed.
Gerard could feel the cool air on his stretched-out back, and the hot, humid air from Frank's body pressed close behind him. The sensation sent shivers down his spine, making his ass clench and unclench reflexively.
He took a deep, shuddery breath, trying to calm his racing heart and focus on the task at hand. The wet sounds of lube being slicked up behind him made his cock throb and leak pre-cum onto the sheets below.
Suddenly, he could feel the blunt, rounded tip of something pressing against his freshly fingered hole. It was an unfamiliar texture, smoother and more uniform than Frank's fingers. Gerard's eyes widened behind the blindfold, his heart pounding.
"Okay... okay, I'm guessing... " he murmured, trying to focus on the sensation. It was cool and sleek, not nearly as hot as Frank's cock would be. But he wasn't sure yet.
The tip pushed forward, slowly sinking into him inch by inch. It stretched him gently, filling him up more than Frank's fingers had. Gerard gasped softly, biting his lip as he tried to concentrate on the unfamiliar shape and size.
"It's... It's not your dick," Gerard muttered, his voice breathy and uncertain. "It's too... too smooth and cool. And the shape is different. I've never felt anything quite like it before..."
He paused, his hips wiggling slightly as he felt another inch sink into him.
"You sure?" Frank asked. Once the toy sank in as far as I could, Frank wiggled it in Gerard's ass to provoke a moan. "We gotta be for sure, right?"
Gerard let out a choked moan, arching his back more as the toy was twisted and turned inside him. "Ahh fuck! Nnngh... n-no, I don't think it's your dick," he panted, gripping the sheets tightly. "The texture is all wrong. Your cock is so much warmer and... and the shape isn't right."
He could feel the sleek silicone shaft sliding against his inner walls as Frank wiggled and moved it around. It stretched him out more with every twist and turn, the unfamiliar pressure and sensation making his toes curl.
Gerard's own cock throbbed and leaked steadily beneath him, the blindfold only heightening every intense feeling. He could feel Frank's breath on his back, the heat of their body so close to his own.
Suddenly, the toy was pulled out, leaving Gerard feeling empty and aching for more. He gasped as the cool air hit his stretched hole, making it clench and flutter.
"Ahh... It's gone," he whimpered softly. "Okay, so... I'm guessing it's a... It's a big dildo. Pretty girthy too, but a toy definitely."
"Hah, not bad, Gee, not bad at all," Frank chuckled, his voice thick with amusement and arousal. "Looks like my cock isn't the only thing you're getting to know real well."
Gerard could feel the mattress shifting beneath him as Frank gracefully slid off the bed. The rustling of fabric and the soft thump of footsteps confirmed his suspicions - Frank was moving around the room.
"Alright, here comes round two, hot stuff," Frank said teasingly as he climbed back onto the bed. The mattress dipped under his weight, and Gerard could feel the heat of his body radiating close behind him. "This one's gonna be a bit trickier to guess. Ready?"
Gerard gulped nervously, his heart pounding in his ears as he waited for whatever came next. "Mmhmm," he breathed out, arching his back to present himself to Frank.
Suddenly, he felt the cool, slick tip of something round and smooth press against his stretched and ready hole. It was much smaller than the previous toy, and more uniform in shape.
Gerard gasped as the small bead popped inside him with a soft squelch. He wiggled his hips reflexively, feeling the unfamiliar sensation of the little orb nestling deep in his ass.
"Ohh..." he whimpered softly, biting his lip as Frank slowly pushed the next bead inside him. Then the next. Each one was a bit bigger than the last, stretching him out gradually.
By the time Frank reached the largest bead in the set, Gerard was making desperate little noises, panting and writhing on the bed. The snug fit of the beads nestled deep inside him was intensely pleasurable and comforting in an odd way.
The beads were pulled out slowly, letting each one pop out with a filthy wet sound and making Gerard gasp and moan with every sensation. His cock was leaking steadily onto the sheets, his body aching for more stimulation.
He panted out, "Okay... so it's round. Smaller than the last toy, but... it felt like little balls. Getting bigger each time... oh fuck... the last one was big..."
Gerard's mind raced with possibilities - it wasn't Frank's cock, but something rounded and uniform. Then it hit him.
"Wait... you put beads in me, didn't you? Fucking hell, Frankie..." he gasped out, his voice strangled with pleasure.
"Dude, don't look at me like that," Frank laughed. This whole 'guess the toy' game was YOUR genius idea, remember? I'm just here to make it super fucking interesting for you."
He reached out and playfully smacked Gerard's ass, watching it jiggle enticingly. "Besides, you know damn well I love a challenge. And nothing gets me more revved up than seeing you all hot and bothered, trying to figure out whether it's my cock or some sexy toy stuffing your tight little hole."
He smirked, running a hand sensuously down Gerard's flank. "Unless of course you want me just to bend you over and fuck you stupid with my real cock instead? 'Cause I'm totally down for that option too."
Gerard shuddered at the smack to his ass, gasping sharply as the stinging slap of skin on skin jolted through him. "Hnnngh... fuck, Frankie. You're a real dick," he grumbled breathlessly, but there was no real heat behind it.
He took a deep breath, trying to focus past the intense pleasure still zinging through his nerves from the beads. Gerard's mind raced as he concentrated on the sensations, trying to pinpoint exactly what the toy was.
"It's... It's beads," he declared with a nod. "Definitely beads. Round and graduated in size. I could feel each one popping in and out as you played with 'em."
Gerard's voice was strained, his breathing heavy and uneven. The blindfold did nothing to hide the flushed, aroused look on his face or the way his cock throbbed and leaked steadily beneath him.
"I can't believe I'm letting you do this to me," he muttered, but there was a hint of laughter in his voice. "You're such a fucking pervert, Frankie."
Gerard arched his back a bit more, presenting his ass to Frank in blatant offer.
"Me, the pervert? Nah, I think we know who's realllly the pervert here. You're the one begging for me to shove toys up that ass of yours,"
He shook his head in mock disbelief, dark eyes glinting with mischief and arousal. "Don't act like you ain't fucking loving every second of this, Gee. We both know you're the one who wanted to play this kinky little game."
Frank reached out to grope and squeeze the firm globes of Gerard's ass, fingers sinking into the supple flesh as he pulls them apart. " You're a mess, man. A beautiful, fucking sexy mess."
Gerard moaned softly, his back arching more as Frank groped and kneaded the firm cheeks of his ass. "Mmm fuck... you're right. I did want this," he admitted breathlessly, a blush coloring his cheeks beneath the blindfold. "I just... I wanted to feel something different. Anything but the usual boring missionary stuff."
He wiggled his hips, grinding back against Frank's teasing touch. Gerard's body was trembling with anticipation, his skin tingling and sensitive after the intense sensations of the beads.
He licked his lips, tasting the saltiness of his own desperate arousal on them. "I just... I wanted you to fuck me stupid, you know? I wanted to be wild and crazy and just... lose myself in the pleasure."
Gerard's voice dropped to a low, needy whimper. "So... so go ahead then. Fuck me. Fuck me like you mean it, Frankie. I want to feel your big, hard cock inside me. I want you to fill me up and fuck me stupid..."
He reached back to spread himself open even further, revealing the tight pink pucker of his hole. It fluttered and clenched, silently begging to be filled by Frank's thick heat.
Gerard's cock throbbed almost painfully now, the swollen head an angry red and dripping with pre-cum. His balls felt so full and heavy, aching for release.
"So you forfeit?" Frank asked jokingly.
Frank's voice was a low, husky rumble, thick with lust and amusement. He gripped Gerard's hips hard enough to leave finger-shaped bruises, pulling him back to grind the leaking tip of his cock against that twitching, eager pucker.
He rolled his hips, letting his cockhead catch and drag against Gerard's rim with each pass. The silky, swollen glans nudged insistently at the center, teasing the sensitive nerves until Gerard was clenching and whimpering.
"You can't just change what we were doing. You fail."
Frank's cockhead popped inside briefly with a filthy squelch before he wrenched himself back out. He chuckled darkly at the desperate sound of Gerard's moan.
"This one's easy," Frank continued. "It's warm, just how you like it."
Gerard gasped and moaned wantonly as he felt the silky, swollen head of Frank's cock nudging and catching on his entrance. His body clenched and fluttered around the teasing intrusion, trying to draw Frank deeper.
"Uhnnn, fuck, Frankie!" he whimpered, his back arching as he pushed back against the maddening stimulation. "I'm not forfeiting, you motherfucker. I'm just... ahh... I want your cock so fucking bad..."
He licked his lips again, panting heavily as he tried to focus past the intense pleasure sparking through his nerves.
Gerard groaned as Frank's cockhead popped inside briefly, the sudden penetration making him see stars. His body clenched down on the brief intrusion, a desperate moan tearing from his throat.
"W-warm..." he gasped out. "It's warm and... fuck, it's your cock. I can feel it's your cock, you fucking tease..."
Gerard's own erection throbbed almost painfully now, the shaft flushed a deep, angry red. His balls felt so tight and full, aching for release.
He writhed beneath Frank, his hips rolling back to chase the feeling of that teasing cock. "Fuck, just... ahh... just quit playing with me, Frankie. I need it. I need your cock, please..."
“Mmm, fuck it,” Frank groaned, his voice low and rough with lust.
He gripped Gerard's hips harder, fingernails digging into the supple flesh as he yanked him back. Frank's thick, hard cock sank deeper into Gerard's tight heat, the swollen crown pushing past that fluttering rim to slip in.
The breath hissed from between Frank's teeth as he felt Gerard's walls spreading open around his throbbing shaft, silken and scorching hot. He rolled his hips, driving another inch or two into Gerard’s hole.
"Shit, you feel fucking incredible," Frank panted, his grip on Gerard's hips tightening. He rocked into him with deliberate, teasing thrusts, letting Gerard feel every rigid inch of his hard cock sinking deeper with each pass.
"That's it, baby. Fucking take it," Frank growled, his eyes dark and intense as they raked over the erotic sight of his lover's body opening for him. "Gonna fill this sexy ass up real good..."
Gerard cried out in ecstasy as finally, blessedly, Frank's thick cock speared into him. His back arched sharply, a scream of pleasure catching in his throat as he was split open on that magnificent shaft.
"fuck, yes!" he roared, his fingers scrabbling at the sheets as he pushed his hips back, impaling himself even deeper on Frank's throbbing erection. "Oh god, Frankie... your cock... it's so fucking big..."
Gerard's head fell forward, his sweat-damp hair falling into his eyes as he panted harshly, struggling to breathe past the intense sensation of being so utterly filled and stretched.
He could feel every throbbing inch of Frank's cock, hot and hard and pulsing inside him. It rubbed against his sensitive walls with each teasing thrust, sending sparks of pleasure shooting up his spine.
Gerard clenched down on Frank's pistoning shaft, his body trembling and shaking like a leaf. Drool leaked from the corner of his mouth, and his eyes rolled back behind the blindfold as he lost himself in the overwhelming ecstasy.
"That's it... ahh... fucking ruin me, Frankie.”
“Yeah, C’mon,” Frank grunted, sweat dripping down his temples as he pistoned his hips faster, the wet slapping of skin on skin echoing through the room.
He angled his thrusts just right, the swollen head of his cock kissing Gerard's prostate dead-on with every plunge. Over and over, he nailed that sensitive bundle of nerves, determined to wring every last drop of ecstasy from Gerard’s quivering form.
Gerard's moans turned into incoherent, garbled cries of rapture, his throat raw from screaming his bliss. His cock, red and dripping, jerked and spasmed untouched as his orgasm crashed over him like a tidal wave. Frank fucked him through it relentlessly, each thrust pushing Gerard higher, making his climax stretch on and on.
With a guttural roar, Frank slammed into Gerard one last time, his cock pulsing and throbbing as it erupted. His hot seed flooded Gerard's clenching hole, painting his insides white with thick ropes of cum. Frank's hips ground against Gerard's ass, pressing in deep as he pumped him full, marking him, claiming him.
“Shit, gonna fill you up so fuckin' good, fuck... ahhh…” Frank groaned, his voice a low, lust-thick rumble. He collapsed forward, blanketing Gerard's sweat-slicked back, both of them gasping and shaking in the aftermath.
Gerard screamed in pure, unadulterated bliss as his orgasm crashed over him like a freight train. His vision went white behind the blindfold as pleasure exploded through every nerve ending, his body convulsing almost violently.
He could feel each thick, hot pulse of Frank's release painting his insides, marking him, claiming him from the inside out. It was filthy, it was raw, and it was everything Gerard had been craving.
Gerard clung to the sheets for dear life, his knuckles white and aching, as Frank's weight pressed down on his back. He panted harshly, gasping for air, his skin slick with sweat and slick with exertion. Frank took that as a chance to take off the blindfold.
Slowly, he turned his head to the side to face Frank, his hazel eyes glazed and fucked-stupid behind the blindfold. A lazy, sated smirk tugged at his kiss-swollen lips.
"Holy shit, Frankie..." Gerard whispered hoarsely, his voice raw. "That was... fuck. Just... wow. Incredible."
He let out a soft, breathless laugh before turning his head to capture Frank's lips in a sloppy, open-mouthed kiss. Gerard licked into his mouth greedily, tasting the salt of his skin and the lingering flavor of their shared passion.
"Thank you," he murmured against Frank's lips. "I didn't know I needed that so badly."
"Yeah? I have something in mind next time," Frank kissed Gerard with a smirk. "Come on, let's get you cleaned up. As much as I know you hate showers, you're all sticky with lube and shit."
Gerard snorted softly and rolled his eyes, but he couldn't suppress the grin tugging at his mouth. "Ugh, fine. But you'd better make it quick," he grumbled playfully.
He sat up slowly, wincing a bit as Frank's seed began to leak out of his well-used hole. The pleasant ache in his ass made him shudder, a giddy laugh bubbling up from his chest.
Gerard stood and stretched languidly, his muscles flexing beneath his smooth skin. He felt a bit wobbly on his feet, a pleasant afterglow still tingling through his body.
“I should make it long to spite you,” Frank said.
Gerard laughed and rolled his eyes. “Fuck you.”
Picking up his clothes from the floor, he shook his head. "And don't think I didn't notice you changing the subject, mister. I know there's more of that 'something' you have planned in store for me later..."
Gerard smirked wickedly and leaned in close, brushing his nose against Frank's neck and inhaling the musky scent of sex and sweat clinging to his skin.
"Good thing I'm not going anywhere anytime soon," he purred.