Work Text:
The cold air on the Pit’s rooftop failed to extinguish the fire Jack felt burning inside. There was Robby, leaning against the railing with indifference tattooed across his face, letting his cigarette smoke vanish into the Pittsburgh sky. There were no preambles. Jack crossed the space with heavy steps marked by rage, and before Robby could exhale the next puff, Jack’s fist connected squarely with his cheekbone.
The sound of the blow was blunt—a crack that left Jack’s hand pulsing with pain.
He grabbed Robby by the shirt collar, shaking him with a force that came from deep within. His knuckles burned, but the adrenaline was stronger. Robby was slightly taller, yet in that moment, he seemed small before Jack’s fury.
"I know you’re in a bad place, man, but... doing that to her?" Jack shook him again, his voice breaking with incredulity. "No picking a higher spot to jump from Seriously, Robby?"
Jack knew that in twenty minutes, perhaps, the weight of the consequences would crash down on him. Or maybe not. But right now, all he could see was the image of a shattered Samira—the smartest and kindest person in that hospital—planning her departure to another place because of the toxicity of the person who was supposed to be her support.
"Are you two sleeping together? Is that why you’re defending her?" Robby spat.
That sentence, loaded with poisonous irony, was the final trigger. Robby was looking to hurt, looking to reduce Samira’s integrity to something dirty to justify his own emptiness. Jack let go of the collar for only a second. As soon as Robby regained his balance, Jack charged again: a second blow, straight to the lip.
He felt the impact in the bones of his hand. “Shit, I’m a doctor,” he thought briefly, aware that his hands were made to heal, not to harm. But he couldn’t stand Samira being the target of Robby’s dark projections.
"Shit, Michael!" Jack yelled at him, giving him a shove that made him stagger.
He saw the blood bloom from his best friend’s mouth. He knew Robby was at the edge of the abyss, in a place so dark he only wanted to burn everything around him before running away. But Jack wasn’t going to allow Samira to be the collateral damage of his fall.
"Just take your fucking bike and leave," Jack sentenced, turning his back on him.
He walked toward the rooftop door without looking back. Once inside, he rubbed his bruised knuckles. His hand hurt, the betrayal of a years-long friendship hurt, but the certainty was absolute: if they asked him if he would hit Robby again to defend Samira, the answer would always be a resounding yes.
An hour before the blood stained the rooftop concrete, the atmosphere in the ER was the usual controlled chaos of the Pit. Jack had just stepped out of Bay 3, pulling off his latex gloves with a sharp movement. His hands, the same ones that would soon close into a fist, were still dedicated to healing.
"Jack, do you have a second?" Dana intercepted him near the nursing station, her expression a mix of fatigue and concern.
"Tell me, Dana. What’s up?" He adjusted his watch and looked at her. The day had been heavy, with Robby exploding at everyone. The whole environment felt tense.
"Dr. Mohan was looking for you. She wanted to talk to you about a letter of recommendation." Dana simply shrugged and shook her head at the look on Jack’s face; everyone was disappointed by the events of that shift.
Jack stood frozen for a second. The word "recommendation" hit his ears like an alarm. In the language of a hospital under pressure, that only meant one thing: someone was giving up. And for it to be Samira—the brightest of them all—felt like a systemic failure.
"Where is she now?" Jack asked, his voice dropping an octave as he searched for her figure among the gurneys.
Santos, who was a few feet away focused on digitizing patient intake records, looked up without stopping his typing.
"She went up the stairs a moment ago," Santos said, gesturing vaguely toward the end of the hall. "Looked like she needed some air."
Jack didn't need further explanation. He knew the corners of that building better than anyone, and he knew that when the weight of the ER became unbearable, the only place to breathe was up. He knew Samira had gone to the roof, likely trying to process the humiliation Robby had put her through following her panic attack and that miserable comment about the suicide attempt patient.
As Jack headed for the stairs, the echo of his prosthesis against the floor seemed to mark a rhythm of urgency. In his mind, the letter of recommendation wasn't just a piece of paper; it was proof that Robby was succeeding in breaking the best of them.
As he climbed the steps, his initial worry began to transform into a cold, directed fury. He wasn’t going to let Samira leave—not like this. And above all, he wasn’t going to let Michael get away with pushing a colleague into the abyss.
When Jack pushed open the metal rooftop door, the cold Pittsburgh air hit his face, but it was the image in front of him that stopped his heart. He froze, hand still gripped around the handle, feeling the blood turn to ice in his veins.
Samira was there. On the other side of the safety railing.
A single step separated her from the void. Her eyes were closed, surrendered to the wind that whipped her brown hair, while sobs escaped her throat in a broken whisper that the air barely allowed to be heard. But Jack heard it. He heard it with a clarity that tore his soul apart.
"He should have found a higher place to jump from..." she repeated, over and over, like a funeral mantra. "A higher place..."
For Jack, the scene was a brutal impact. Seeing the woman he loved on the edge of the abyss was a nightmare come true. Because he loved her; he had known it since the first day he saw her walk in as a resident, lighting up the grey hallways of the ER with an intelligence that took his breath away. He felt deeply guilty. He had seen, month after month, how the pressure of the Pit and the toxicity of the system swallowed the kind girl, turning her light into ashes.
His memories flew back to Pittfest. That procedure he encouraged her to perform, the shared adrenaline, the hours of practice, and the conversations that stretched until dawn. That was where it all became undeniable. But Jack was her attending. He had always kept his distance, respecting that power dynamic he didn't dare break; he didn't want to fail her, he didn't want to be another complication in her career.
But now, seeing her there, repeating Robby’s poisonous words, something changed inside him. Ethics and hierarchies vanished before the urgency of saving her.
"Samira," Jack whispered, taking a nearly imperceptible step, his heart hammering against his ribs. "Samira, look at me. Please, look at me."
His voice trembled. It wasn't the attending physician speaking; it was the man who couldn't imagine a world where she didn't exist. In that moment, as he watched her feet at the edge of the concrete, the fury against Robby began to brew in his gut—a rage that would explode just an hour later. But now, the only thing that mattered was for her to take a step back.
Samira didn't even move. The wind continued to lash her hair, but she seemed to be on another plane, one where only the weight of her mistakes existed. Jack remained petrified a few meters away, fear tightening his throat, listening as she broke down her own ruin in a voice devoid of hope.
"I failed, Doctor Abbot... like never before," she murmured, each word a blow to him. "Mr. Diaz has brain damage because I wasn't able to stop him. He slipped through my fingers, on my watch... and now his life is nothing."
Jack tried to speak, but Samira continued, emptying the poison that burned her chest. She told him about the resident under her charge, about the error she didn't see coming, and about that other patient who died because she, the "brilliant" Samira, simply didn't check on him in time.
"I’m failing at the only thing I thought I was good at," she sobbed, and the sound was a tear in the air. "If I’m not this, if I’m not a good doctor... what do I have left?"
Jack felt a fierce helplessness. He knew Samira had been at her limit for weeks. The constant uncertainty about her mother’s and well-being had left her defenseless, and the panic attack in the middle of the ER had been the final crack. But what was truly pushing her into the void was Robby’s voice echoing in her head, the public humiliation, and that cruel sentence she was now using as justification to end it all.
"Dr. Robby was right today," she whispered, leaning barely a centimeter forward. "I made so many mistakes today..."
"No!" Jack shouted, finally breaking his paralysis. He took a firm step, ignoring protocol, ignoring his position as attending. "Samira, listen to me. Robby is a coward who only knows how to hurt when he’s sinking himself. What happened today... the mistakes, the chaos... they don’t define you. The Pit swallows people, but you aren't like the others. You are the most human person I know."
He reached out his hand, his heart in his throat, internally begging her not to take that final step. In that instant, seeing the fragility of the woman he loved, the seed of violence against Robby finished germinating. If he managed to get her down from there, if he managed to save her from herself, he would personally see to it that Robby paid for every one of Samira’s tears.
"Give me your hand, Samira. Please. Don't let him win." He whispered in a low, slightly shaky voice: it was a plea.
Samira fell silent for a second that felt like an eternity to Jack. Slowly, she turned her body, her face soaked in tears and her brown eyes clouded by emotional exhaustion. Seeing Jack—not the attending, but the man looking at her with palpable devotion and fear—the rigidity in her shoulders vanished.
She reached her hands toward him, trembling.
Jack didn't waste a second. He moved to the safety railing and took her by the wrists with a protective firmness, helping her cross back to the safe side of the roof. As soon as her feet touched solid ground, Samira collapsed against him. Jack wrapped his arms around her with almost desperate strength, as if trying to hold together all the pieces of her that the hospital had tried to break.
She hid her face in the crook of his neck, sobbing so hard her entire body vibrated. Jack buried his face in her curly hair, breathing in her scent and letting his own breathing stabilize as he felt her safe.
"Listen to me carefully, Samira," he whispered in her ear, his voice charged with absolute conviction. "You are the smartest person I have ever known in my life. You aren't just good; you are the future of medicine. You are the reason this place still has some humanity left."
Jack pulled her tighter, stroking her back while she clung to his shirt.
"We are all allowed to break, Samira. Everyone. Even you." Jack paused, wanting his next words to be etched into her mind. "And nothing that happened today was your fault. I read the charts before I came up. I reviewed all of them. It wasn't your fault, Samira. The system failed, the patient didn't mention anything, but you did everything humanly possible. Don't carry deaths that don't belong to you."
Jack held her as if she were the most valuable thing that had ever passed through that hospital. He felt the trembling of her body against his—a fragility that broke his soul but, at the same time, ignited a fierce protective instinct within him. While Samira’s crying dampened his neck, Jack made a silent decision: he would not allow anyone to trample on her again.
In his mind, he was already tracing plans. He would take her out of the line of fire of the morning shifts where Robby could reach her. He would bring her to the night shift with him; there, under the fluorescent lights and the tense silence of the early morning, he would make sure she felt valued. He would put her in a glass box if necessary—not to hide her, but so no one else could tarnish her brilliance. He would foster every one of her skills, reminding her in every case, in every suture, why she was the best.
Because he loved her. It was a truth that could no longer be hidden from himself, even if the code of ethics dictated otherwise.
But Jack was a man of honor, and his love for her was greater than his own ego. If Samira could only see him as a friend, he would be the immovable pillar she could always lean on. If she only needed a mentor, he would be the most patient and wise guide she could have, pushing her to reach that greatness he already saw in her.
"Easy, Samira... it’s over now," he whispered, kissing the crown of her head with infinite tenderness. "I'm not going to let you sink. I’ve got you."
He stayed there, allowing her to empty all her pain, savoring the bitter satisfaction of being the one who rescued her. However, as he stroked Samira’s hair, his eyes turned icy as he looked toward the rooftop door.
The moment of tenderness was for her, but the moment of justice... that would be for Robby.
Jack no longer felt just sadness for his friend; he felt that Robby had crossed a line from which there was no return. He had tried to destroy the woman Jack loved, and that was something no "crisis" or shared history could save. Those knuckles that were now caressing Samira were about to meet Robby’s face.